YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Judge Irving Still Hopes for Call to Head the FBI : If President Taps Him, Fans of San Diego Jurist Say, the Nation Will Get the Ideal Man as Its Top Cop

March 15, 1987|JIM SCHACHTER | Times Staff Writer

First came the hints--the vague, adulatory column items nearly a year ago saying U.S. District Judge J. Lawrence Irving was under consideration for an important federal post.

Then came the opportunity--the announcement early this month that President Reagan had tabbed FBI Director William H. Webster as the man to take over the CIA.

Not more than a day later came the humble confirmation:

Yes, Irving told one columnist, his name was in the hopper for the FBI job. "I'm going to be considered," he said. "And if they asked, I doubt anybody could turn that down."

What had been rumored for a year now has become a matter of record. Larry Irving, lavishly lauded in San Diego but barely a blip on the national criminal justice scene, is engaged in a dark-horse campaign for the nation's top law enforcement job.

His fans--and they are legion--say he would be perfect for the post: a model of integrity, a conservative who has the guts to draw the line against investigative excess, a cool and collected leader who quickly gets his hands on every assignment he draws.

But can a federal district judge in faraway San Diego, no matter how well he is regarded at home, be taken seriously as a candidate for so high-level a Washington position? And is Irving, 52, doing what he needs to do to outpoint better-known contenders for a presidential nod?

The judge readily acknowledges he wants the job. "I can't think of a more exciting, interesting, challenging job in the United States or the world," he said in a recent interview.

But he is not talking about his strategy for getting it.

"I'm frankly reluctant to say much because I don't want anyone involved in the appointing process to think, 'Who is this judge in San Diego who has the arrogance to think he's being considered?' " Irving said.

He insists, too, that he isn't the sort to engage in an obvious drum-beating campaign on his own behalf. "I don't know how these things work," Irving said. "I pretty much have not been involved politically."

Don't think for a moment that there's anything unsophisticated about Irving, a multimillionaire who was considered one of San Diego's top trial lawyers before his appointment to the federal bench in 1982.

But it is a fact that Irving has not busied himself touching base with the power brokers who often have played a kingmaker role for San Diegans seeking federal appointments during the Reagan era.

He has not gone, hat in hand, to Great American Savings and Loan Assn. Chairman Gordon Luce, a self-described "junior member" of Reagan's kitchen cabinet and a longtime associate of Atty. Gen. Edwin Meese III, the La Mesan who will recommend a new FBI director to the President.

He has not broken bread with financier Tom Stickel or radio executive Allan Royster, powerful younger Turks in the city's Republican Establishment. He hasn't paid a courtesy call on former Rep. Clair W. Burgener, gray eminence of the county GOP.

Nor has he contacted his congressman, Rep. Bill Lowery (R-San Diego), or checked in with his senator, Pete Wilson (R-Calif.), who eventually will vote on whichever nominee the President selects.

It isn't that Irving doesn't know how to get something he wants, however. It's just that he prefers the direct route.

"He let the President's office and the attorney general's office become aware he's had a lifelong interest in that role as head of the FBI," said retired San Diego County Superior Court Judge William Yale, a longtime friend.

Yale said Irving had talked directly about the job with Meese, whom he knew as a fellow lawyer in San Diego and with whom, according to Yale, he is on a first-name basis. Associates say Irving quietly put the word out about his interest last spring, when two years remained in Webster's 10-year term.

"He has not gone out on a full-court press to ask everybody he knows to write a letter or send a telegram," Yale said.

Irving is suave and low key, and a full-court press wouldn't be his style. Given the circles in which Irving travels, however, all that may not be necessary as he seeks the biggest job of his career.

"He's thought of favorably by a number of members of the Administration and/or by close advisers of the Administration," said another friend, John Seiber, a vice president with the Paine Webber brokerage firm in San Diego. "I would think those types of things would stand him in good stead."

Indeed, though Irving has not solicited Luce's support, Luce has lent it, according to Great American spokesman Kenneth Ulrich. Government officials recently have sought Luce's evaluation of Irving, and Luce has given a thumbs-up.

"Gordon's official position is that he does encourage his candidacy," Ulrich said last week. "He does think he'd be an excellent choice for the job, and he has made some public statements--public in the sense of to other people, government people and whatnot."

Los Angeles Times Articles