YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Gypsies Take Fight Against Age-Old Stigma Into Court

December 13, 1987|SANTIAGO O'DONNELL | Times Staff Writer

The report from Probation Officer Will Manson, written last July, stated that burglary suspect Walter Larson, 37, "along with other weak-minded scheming Gypsies wormed their way into elderly victims' residences with the sole purpose of stealing various items of value. . . .

"Realistically, not much is known about this defendant, other than he is a Gypsy who undoubtedly has been living on the fringes of the law for a long period of time."

Manson's job was to report as thoroughly as possible on Larson's background to help the Long Beach Superior Court judge deliver his sentence. Weeks later, the Montebello resident was handed a five-year prison term for having taken $130 in four residential burglaries committed in Long Beach over a period of four hours in 1984.

Several years ago, perhaps few people would have complained about the language in the probation report or the tough sentence slapped on a first-time offender whose only previous conviction resulted in a $50 fine for fighting with his cousin. After all, for centuries Gypsies have been stigmatized as being little more that a bunch of filthy, devious, roaming fortunetellers.

But in 1984 the U.S. Romani (Gypsy) Council was formed to fight racial prejudice, and today it spearheads a civil rights movement that has chosen the Larson case to take a stand on. His trial, they believe, was tainted with the racist undertones and references to precisely the kind of negative stereotypes they are trying to eradicate.

"This is the most important case in Gypsy history," said anthropologist Ruth Anderson of the University of Texas who has spent 15 years studying Gypsy communities. "For the first time, they are standing up and objecting to discrimination instead of hiding or moving on to the next town."

Indeed, attorney Barry Fisher last week asked Superior Court Judge Charles Sheldon to reconsider Larson's sentence. "The trial was so contaminated by the racist language included in the probation report that it prevented Larson from receiving the fair trial he is entitled to under United States law," Fisher contended

Sitting behind Fisher in the courtroom Monday were John Merino, a real estate agent who heads the California chapter of the U.S. Romani Council, and Anderson, who had flown in for the hearing. On the next aisle were four members of Larson's family, all impeccably dressed in business suits and sober dresses.

And lying on the bench were letters from Merino; Ian Hancock, a U.S. delegate to the United Nations representing the International Romani Union, and Rep. Tom Lantos (D-San Mateo), all condemning the language in Manson's report.

Sentence 'Unusually Stiff'

Lantos, calling the sentence "unusually stiff," asked the judge to "take great care in the fact that (Larson) is a Romani does not weigh against him or interfere with his constitutional rights."

It was the first time that either the council or the union has spoken up on behalf of a Gypsy facing criminal charges.

The defense also submitted letters from neighbors and former customers who used Larson's services as a paving contractor vouching for the defendant's good conduct and depicting him as a responsible husband and father of four. In addition, the thick file before the judge included a lengthy sworn declaration by Anderson sketching the history of discrimination against the Gypsies. An estimated 500,000 were killed during the Holocaust.

They also complained that Sheldon specified that Larson serve the five-year sentence after completing time served on a separate federal charge. After his burglary arrest in 1984, Larson jumped bail and paid $5,000 to an undercover FBI agent to clear his record. He was rearrested several years later and is serving a three-year sentence for bribery. The defense claims that because of his limited knowledge of English and the American judicial system, Larson was not aware that he was committing bribery.

While the defense's motion was being heard in court, Manson sat behind his desk in the probation office unaware that a hearing based on his report was taking place elsewhere in the state building.

He remembered the Larson report but not in detail since it had been filed five months earlier. After rereading it, the veteran of 22 years with the Probation Department had no apologies.

'Shouldn't Say That'

"I didn't mean that all Gypsies are 'weak-minded,' but this guy obviously was since he was stealing from elders . . . and Gypsies are scheming, although I shouldn't say that. It would be an indictment. And 'worming,' well that's just figurative language."

Manson's boss, Phillip Stein, deputy director of the Probation Department's field services unit, was also unaware of the Larson hearing. But when he found out two days later, he did not hesitate to repudiate Manson's report.

Los Angeles Times Articles