Advertisement
YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Old East Bloc Hostilities Surface as Threats to Infant Democracies : Europe: Poles fear Germans. Czechs are divided. Hungarians hold old grudges against Romanians. Reborn Europe faces severe growing pains.

December 17, 1989|Tad Szulc | Veteran correspondent Tad Szulc has covered Eastern Europe since World War II

WASHINGTON — Nationalism, ethnic identity and religion played crucial roles in shattering the communist domination of Eastern Europe. As the extraordinary forces of an extraordinary 1989, they were more powerful than the Moscow brand of Marxism-Leninism imposed four decades ago.

Identical forces rise in non-Russian republics of the Soviet Union and they erupt in communist Yugoslavia. The process seems to portend the end of a historical cycle begun with Russia's 1917 Revolution.

Yet nationalism, ethnicity and religion may also create problems no less profound in post-communist Eastern Europe--antagonisms between countries and within them. Positive forces can become negative forces, undermining the effort to build democracies, reconstruct economies and assure reasonable social harmony.

The most difficult problems could involve relationships between Poland and the German Democratic Republic--East Germany.

In the immediate aftermath of World War II, Stalin annexed Poland's easternmost territories, roughly one-third of the country, while awarding to Poland Germany's eastern provinces up to the Oder and Neisse rivers. Millions of Germans were expelled in the process, losing homes and businesses, and being forced to flee to East or West Germany.

Long before the fall of communist regimes in Poland and East Germany this year, serious frictions had developed between the two governments despite mutual memberships in the Warsaw Pact and Comecon, the communist common market. Polish and East German warships fired at each other off the Baltic coast over fishing rights; East German organizations kept alive anti-Polish revanchism.

A territorial issue exploded only last month, with the collapse of the East German communist regime. The sudden possibility of German reunification reopened old sores on both sides of the Oder-Neisse border. Ethnic Germans who had stayed behind on the Polish side began organizing what Warsaw regarded as anti-Polish associations. The East German regime forbade Polish citizens to shop for goods on the German side of the frontier.

Earlier this month, Warsaw's Gazeta Wyborcza, the new democratic newspaper with the largest circulation in Poland, charged that "explosions of anti-Polish phobia" among Germans were threatening the democratic order in Europe. The front-page editorial appeared just as the Polish government headed by Prime Minister Tadeusz Mazowiecki, a Solidarity leader, made clear that Poland would accept German reunification only after all Germans, East and West, formally recognized the Oder-Neisse line (as the Western Allies had done long ago).

Finally, West German Foreign Minister Hans-Dietrich Genscher felt the need to announce that "it is completely clear that Germans do not question the Polish western border--now or in the future." But the issue remains. Chancellor Helmut Kohl made no such assurances to the Poles in his 10-point program for German unification and Genscher's comment may have no impact on German public opinion, East or West.

The peril is not a new Balkanizing of sovereignties or frontiers but the threat of confrontations among former Soviet satellites and internal chaos. Throwbacks to oppression, if not neo-Fascism and anti-Semitism, could result.

Nationalistic or ethnic resentments were papered over during the decades of Soviet control, to present an image of communist unity to the outside world.

Problems in Czechoslovakia also date back to the 1940s. At the end of World War II, more than 2 million ethnic Germans were expelled from Czech lands by the Soviets. Those people are now agitating in Germany for what they regard as their right to return and regain their properties.

In Poland and Czechoslovakia, domestic public opinion angrily opposes such agitation, emphasizing that the Germans appear to forget that the existing state of affairs was a response to Hitler's war and Nazi occupation.

To protect themselves from German demands, the Poles insist on a clear understanding with both Germanys on the inviolability of present borders "before it is too late," as the Solidarity newspaper put it the other day.

Territorial problems also exist between Hungary, now moving toward parliamentary democracy, and Romania, still under a Stalin-style dictatorship, over Transylvania. Stalin had given almost half of the long-disputed Transylvanian territory to Romania as a reward, because her armies joined the Soviets in the closing days of the war after abandoning the Wehrmacht . Hungary did not switch sides. Now Budapest complains that ethnic Hungarians are ill-treated in Romanian Transylvania--and thousands try to flee.

Advertisement
Los Angeles Times Articles
|
|
|