Proponents of an open primary cite the victory in the 1992 Republican U.S. Senate primary by Bruce Herschensohn as evidence that the existing closed primary exaggerates the influence of extreme voters ("Rival Parties Unite Against Open Primary," March 20). This is putting the blame in the wrong place. Herschensohn's principal opponent, Tom Campbell, did not lose because moderate Democratic and independent voters were unable to vote in the Republican primary--as they could if Prop. 198 were in effect--but because moderate voters were split between Campbell and a third candidate, Sonny Bono.
Outcomes like the 1992 primary could be prevented by switching to either a system in which primary voters rank-order their preferences (the "alternative vote") or one in which voters vote for as many candidates in their party's primary as they wish (the "approval vote"). Either system would have allowed Campbell to win the primary without forcing Republicans to open their primary to non-Republican voters, because Bono's voters would also have cast ballots for Campbell, and not for the more extreme Herschensohn.