YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

The Cutting Edge

Design Departure

Aerospace: 'Lean' is the new watchword as industry, the military and academia join forces to revolutionize the way planes are made.


Nearly every kid who has been to an airport or a military air show has pointed to a jetliner or a fighter plane and asked with wonder, "How did they make that?"

These days, executives at the country's aerospace titans and the military's top officials are doing the same thing.

With the help of no less an engineering powerhouse than the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, representatives from industry and government are reexamining the way aircraft of all types are designed and produced. Taking the lead from a groundbreaking study of the Japanese auto industry, they are rethinking the long-held tenets of mass production and changing their corporate cultures in order to make better planes using fewer resources.

In less than five years, this partnership, dubbed the Lean Aerospace Initiative, has resulted in efficiency gains of up to 75% in some of the 16 companies involved in the program. Now the firms are preparing to implement the principles of lean manufacturing on a grand scale for even greater savings.

"The aerospace field has been driven by performance goals more than affordability and manufacturability goals," said Earll Murman, an MIT aeronautics and astronautics professor who is the initiative's program director. "That no longer builds competitive companies. I don't mean to say that performance is unimportant, but a well-performing product which is not affordable or takes too much time to market is not going to be successful."

Much of the U.S. aerospace industry was facing a dubious future in 1993, when defense contractors were feeling the economic impact of the Cold War's demise. With shrinking budgets, Lt. Gen. Thomas R. Ferguson Jr., then chief of the Air Force's Aeronautical Systems Center at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio, saw that major adjustments would be required for both the industry and the military, which had gotten very comfortable with seemingly limitless budgets.

He contacted MIT, where professors had turned Japan's auto makers inside-out to learn how they made consistently reliable cars at low prices.

What they found was a lean production system that emphasized perfect first-time quality, waste minimization and continuous improvement. To achieve these goals, the Japanese companies included manufacturing workers on engineering design teams to ensure that the designs would be easy to build. They also streamlined inventories and allowed workers to perform more tasks and stop production lines when flaws were found.

While the U.S. auto industry was beginning to incorporate the principles of lean production, MIT decided to study how they could be applied to aerospace manufacturing. The university has devoted about 45 people--faculty, researchers and graduate students--to the Lean Aerospace Initiative, and participating companies contribute hundreds of their employees to the effort. The project has an annual budget of $3 million, funded by industry and the federal government.

Research groups in the initiative are now focusing on product development, factory operations and supplier relations as they search for ways to streamline the production process. They are also studying how government policy affects the efficiency of manufacturers, and a new group will look at space operations, Murman said.

Unlike traditional aerospace research--in which data come from wind tunnel tests or computer simulations of fluid dynamics--the Lean Aerospace Initiative requires creative approaches to data gathering because it is the company being studied, not its airplane, said Thomas Allen, a professor in MIT's Sloan School of Management and co-director of the initiative.

Some information, like cost data, can be culled from company records. Other questions, such as the degree to which firms are using computer-aided design programs, must be answered through surveys and interviews. In some cases, MIT researchers act like anthropologists, simply observing what goes on on the factory floor.

The results of this research have already made their way into companies around the country, including the top three defense contractors--Lockheed Martin Corp. in Bethesda, Md.; Seattle's Boeing Co.; and Raytheon Co. in Lexington, Mass.

"Lean production is a new way of doing business," said Don Meadows, director of strategic planning for operations with Lockheed Martin Aeronautical Systems in Marietta, Ga. "It's not just something you apply to manufacturing, but to engineering, accounting and marketing as well."

That sentiment notwithstanding, most companies have started small, making specific improvements to particular lines rather than initiating complete overhauls.

At Northrop Grumman Corp., for example, the company has implemented more than 50 reforms since it became involved with the initiative, said Ed Harmon, team leader for lean and agile manufacturing.

Los Angeles Times Articles