YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

The Puzzle of God

AS IT IS IN HEAVEN;\o7 By Niall Williams; (Warner: 310 pp., $23)\f7

July 04, 1999|JONATHAN LEVI

Ireland and Italy--two God-riven countries separated by a common religion--are the subject of Niall Williams' second novel, "As It Is in Heaven." It's hard to think of a more dramatic contrast (at least within Europe) for a writer to wrestle onto the page.

Stephen Griffin is a 32-year-old from Dublin, a tall, ungainly stork of a loner, living with the ghosts of his dead mother and sister at the edge of the sea on the west coast of County Clare. Gabriella Castoldi is a few years older, a classical violinist from Venice who has remained in Ireland following the failure of a love affair. An intensely unhappy woman, she brings a "cold passion--a frowning intensity" to her playing, especially to her playing of Vivaldi, the patron composer of her hometown.

Nevertheless, on the cold and rainy night when Stephen first sees Gabriella perform at the Old Ground Hotel in Ennis, the magic of Gabriella's quartet-playing produces a warmth that soaks through Stephen's jacket and shirt and heart and leaves him hopelessly in love. Deserting his school post and ailing father, Stephen follows Gabriella, happy just to be in her presence and the aura of her playing. And then one night, at a concert in Kenmare, Gabriella looks up from her music stand and finds Stephen in the third row of the audience. "A quality of longing in his look pierced her, and as she pressed into her chin rest, she had to steady herself against the suddenness of feeling. . . . Then, as unexpectedly as life, Gabriella Castoldi walked down amongst the chairs and the departing audience to Stephen Griffin and asked him if he would like to walk out into the fog with her."

It is a promising, romantic overture, the feverish dream of any groupie, to have the worshiped icon--whether it be a classical Cecilia Bartoli or a baroque Leonardo DiCaprio--descend from the altar for a stroll in the dark. But as the novel plays on from this overture, the twists of the plot become progressively more jarring. Within a few pages, Stephen modulates from stalker to saint. "As unexpectedly as life," Gabriella takes Stephen to her bed for "a brief season--a time which glimmered with the quality of fables."

Then, of course, boy has to lose girl--to Venice, of all places. But there's a ciabatta in the oven (or is it Irish soda bread?), so back to Ireland she comes. The two players are rejoined but, strangely, not as a coherent duet. The effect is always of two indistinct instruments playing different melodies at the same time, an effect that fails so spectacularly to sing to the human heart that one wonders whether the fault lies with the two countries, whether the two cultures are simply too dissimilar to harmonize.

It made me think back on a glimpse of Ireland from Italy I had earlier in the year. When the Royal Court Theatre received the European Theatre Prize in Taormina, Italy, it decided to present "The Weir," by Williams' fellow Irishman Conor McPherson. At first glance, there was something wholly inappropriate in their choice of a play. Taormina is a city of sunshine and sparkling sea, of Greek ruins and Sicilian wine. How would they move from that balmy sunset to the drafty winter of a rural Irish bar and the ghost stories that make up McPherson's drama?

Yet two hours later, the infernal scar of red lava on the cheek of Etna shone cold with the Irish ghosts that followed the audience out of the theater into the full darkness of the night. For McPherson not only has the Irishman's gift for language but something equally important--an ear for the ethereal terrors that move men and women of flesh and blood to do terrible and, often, ordinary things.

And therein, perhaps, lies the beginning of an understanding of why Williams has doomed himself to failure. For Williams, the ethereal is the province not of humans but of the real hero of his novel--God. "There are only three great puzzles in the world," he says in the opening, "the puzzle of love, the puzzle of death, and, between each of these and part of both of them, the puzzle of God."

Williams' theology suggests that not only will God's will be done "on Earth as it is in Heaven," but that our own wills, our own futures, will be determined by heavenly signs. Even earthly, human love, the love of Stephen and Gabriella, of Stephen's father and his dead mother, is but a reflection and product of "[t]he love that moves the sun and the other stars," as the author quotes Dante's "Paradiso" in an opening epigram.

Los Angeles Times Articles