YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

The State

Davis' Energy Advisors Draw SEC Attention

Probe: Under review is the possible use of inside information to buy power company stocks. GOP rival of governor requested the inquiry.


The Securities and Exchange Commission has launched a preliminary inquiry into whether energy consultants advising Gov. Gray Davis used inside information to trade stocks of power companies doing business with the state, a source with knowledge of the matter said Monday.

The federal agency began its review late last week, the source said, in response to a request from California Secretary of State Bill Jones. A Republican rival of Davis, Jones charged that stock trading by consultants may have violated federal laws barring buying and selling based on information not available to the public.

On Friday, top aides to the governor disclosed that five consultants had been fired for possible conflicts of interest between their official positions and their personal finances.

As news of the SEC inquiry spread through the capital Monday, Davis officials were confronted by a flurry of questions about who in the administration owns energy stocks.

Financial disclosure records filed by the governor's spokesman, Steve Maviglio, show that he owns between $10,000 and $100,000 in a Texas company he and his boss have accused of making "obscene" profits while California has been "on its knees." Maviglio said he bought the shares in Houston-based Enron Corp. in 1996.

"It's not a crime to own energy stock," Maviglio said.

He also owns 300 shares of San Jose-based Calpine Corp., which has the largest share of the $43 billion in long-term state power contracts.

Maviglio placed the order for the stock on May 31, one day after San Jose's mayor dropped his opposition to a controversial Calpine plant favored by the governor and others. Under the terms of Maviglio's purchase, the transaction was completed about three weeks later when the stock reached $40 a share, a value of $12,000. It has since fallen in value.

"I viewed it as a good long-term investment," Maviglio said, adding that he purchased the shares for his retirement account based on publicly available information.

The Davis administration has spared Calpine the kind of fierce criticisms that it has leveled at other electricity suppliers, such as Enron. But California's grid operator has identified the company as one of many energy merchants to overcharge the state millions of dollars.

The fired consultants also owned shares in Calpine, ranging in value from several thousand dollars to more than $100,000, records show.

Another top Davis administration official, legal affairs secretary Barry Goode, disclosed in his economic interest statement that he recently held between $100,000 and $1 million in another out-of-state company accused of multimillion-dollar price gouging.

In a statement, Goode said he sold his stock in Williams Co's. a month after he began working for the governor in February. Goode said the shares were supposed to be sold before he went on the state payroll, but his broker failed to do so.

In light of the recent disclosures, Secretary of State Jones said the governor must do more to ensure the public that its interest comes first.

"The governor should direct all of his staff to immediately file updated conflict of interest statements that reflect current holdings and any activity since their last statement of economic interest was filed," said Jones, who is seeking the GOP nomination for governor.

Word of the SEC's entry into California's energy problems comes as the governor faces harsh criticism from lawmakers and others for the quick and broad hiring of highly paid private consultants to guide him through the crisis.

In his written request to the SEC, Jones said that recently filed disclosure documents showed that at least one consultant bought and sold shares of two energy companies within the same month, raising "a red flag" about the possibility of insider trading.

State law prohibits officials from participating in decisions involving their personal financial interests.

The five consultants fired last week were among 11 named in Jones' letter, delivered to the San Francisco office of the SEC last Wednesday. It was not clear which individuals are the focus of the SEC's inquiry, or whether the agency's review would result in any charges.

Two of the former traders said Monday that they had not been contacted by federal investigators and knew nothing of an inquiry into possible insider trading.

But William Mead, fired Thursday, said it is no mystery why so many of his colleagues owned Calpine stock.

Mead said he bought it 2 1/2 years ago and made so much money he recommended it to his colleagues last year, while they all still worked for the now-defunct California Power Exchange in Alhambra. Calpine power was not traded on that exchange, so there was no conflict of interest, he said.

Los Angeles Times Articles