Advertisement
YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

THE WORLD

Aid Agencies Pulling Out of Iraq as Violence Rises

Bush asks the groups not to leave but, as in Afghanistan, many find that insurgents are targeting their staff and hindering relief efforts.

November 15, 2003|Sonni Efron and Shweta Govindarajan | Times Staff Writers

WASHINGTON — President Bush appealed to international aid groups Friday not to abandon their efforts in Iraq, where some agency officials say they are targets of an unprecedented campaign of violence by insurgents.

"It is very important for the leaders of the NGOs [nongovernmental organizations] to recognize that if they don't go into Baghdad, they're doing exactly what the terrorists want them to do," Bush told reporters. "We will stay the course, and as more and more Iraqis realize freedom is precious and freedom is a beautiful way of life, they will assume more and more responsibilities, not only for security, but for humanitarian reasons as well."

After three deadly bombings at the headquarters of the United Nations and the International Committee of the Red Cross in Baghdad, Bush administration officials have said they understand the decisions by those organizations and others to withdraw their international staff. The administration insists that its reconstruction efforts are progressing despite an increase in attacks. Bush's plea reflected the administration's desire to enlist the international community in the costly rebuilding of Iraq.

But the president's pitch seemed unlikely to reverse the exodus of aid workers who in some cases are handing their work over to Iraqis and, in others, abandoning areas that are too dangerous.

"The threats facing aid workers in Iraq are without comparison to any other region in the world," said Nathaniel Raymond, spokesman for Oxfam America, which operates in more than 100 countries. "These attacks are frequent, sophisticated and very specifically targeted to kill humanitarian personnel, intimidate aid groups and hinder operations.

"I don't know of any situation where we have been so effectively as an aid community unable to operate," Raymond said.

In interviews with 15 of the largest aid organizations operating in Iraq -- some of which also are active in Afghanistan -- several said they were working in more stable areas of Iraq and had not had to curtail their activities. A spokeswoman for the U.S. Agency for International Development said that although insecurity was a problem, the agency saw no evidence that it had had a significant impact on the pace of reconstruction.

But other veteran aid officials said relief workers were finding themselves in the cross hairs of what one described as an "unprecedented assault" in both Iraq and Afghanistan. Another aid official said insurgents were carrying out an "active campaign of assassinations" that had succeeded in slowing relief and reconstruction efforts in parts of each beleaguered nation.

Some agencies say the neutrality that enables them to work safely in conflict zones has been jeopardized by having to work under a U.S. military occupation. But administration officials point out that Iraqi hostility to the U.N. and some Western agencies was nurtured by Saddam Hussein's propaganda during a decade of international sanctions.

In Afghanistan, where attacks on aid workers have increased from about one a month a year ago to nearly one a day, entire regions of the country are off-limits to Western relief workers. Twelve aid workers have been killed and dozens wounded since March, according to a survey of the 10 largest charities operating in Afghanistan that was conducted by CARE, an international relief organization.

A chilling incident was the execution-style murder of Ricardo Munguia, 39, a Red Cross water engineer who was helping to dig wells in a remote Afghan village. The man who shot Munguia in the head had lost a leg and was wearing a prosthesis of a type most probably provided by the Red Cross, survivors of the incident told authorities.

At least four of the dead are Afghan aid workers executed in September as part of what appears to be a systematic campaign to punish Afghans who cooperate with international aid organizations or the U.S.-backed government of Hamid Karzai.

The four victims, who worked for a Danish aid group, were killed by suspected Taliban militants who said the workers had to be punished for ignoring warnings not to help Western relief agencies, an Afghan survivor of the attack told authorities.

Also in September, a notice stuck on the front gate of a CARE compound in the same province where the workers were slain told Afghans to "separate yourself from the Jews and Christian community." It warned them not to attend the funerals of people killed while working for foreign NGOs.

The attacks continued this week. On Tuesday, a car bomb exploded outside a U.N. office in Kandahar, in southern Afghanistan. And on Wednesday, a bomb exploded near the offices of Save the Children in Kabul, the Afghan capital. There were no casualties.

Advertisement
Los Angeles Times Articles
|
|
|