YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

The Nation

Al Qaeda Finances Down, Panel Says

But the 9/11 commission says the terrorist network is still dangerous because its attacks are relatively inexpensive.

August 22, 2004|Greg Miller | Times Staff Writer

WASHINGTON — Financial support for Al Qaeda and the size of its operating budget have plummeted in the three years since the Sept. 11 attacks, but the network "continues to fund terrorist operations with relative ease," according to new findings released Saturday by the commission that investigated the strikes.

The report from the panel also says that the Saudi government provided lackluster cooperation to stanch the flow of money to Al Qaeda for two years after the attacks, but began to respond more aggressively after several Al Qaeda strikes in the kingdom last year.

Al Qaeda's annual budget appears to have shrunk from about $30 million a year before the Sept. 11 attacks to as little as a few million dollars a year now, the commission reported. Funding for the terrorist network has shriveled during that period, partly because of the more aggressive stance by Saudi Arabia in combating Al Qaeda financial support, the report said.

But the financial falloff has not caused a commensurate decline in Al Qaeda's capabilities because the attacks it sponsors are relatively inexpensive. It has shed high-cost obligations, including its support for the Taliban in Afghanistan, and the network can still find ready funding from its most solid supporters, the report said.

The findings were released in an exhaustive study of Al Qaeda's financing that was completed by the Sept. 11 commission's investigative staff. The material served as a basis for several sections in the commission's final report, released last month, that dealt with terrorist financing. But the study released Saturday was more lengthy and detailed than those sections of the final report.

The commission also released a comprehensive account of Al Qaeda's exploitation of lax U.S. border and immigration security. The report, released late Saturday, documents the entry of the Sept. 11 hijackers into the country, including their acquisitions of visas, contacts with consular and immigration officials, and other details of their movements.

"These are additional findings of the staff that we thought would further inform people," said Sept. 11 commission spokesman Al Felzenberg. He noted that the new findings were not voted on by the members of the bipartisan panel, which officially shut its offices Saturday after a 20-month investigation.

The 155-page document on financing, called a "monograph on terrorist financing," examines Al Qaeda's methods of raising and distributing money, the specific financing of the Sept. 11 plot, and the U.S. government's often frustrated efforts to track terrorist funding in the years before and after the attacks.

Overall, the report concludes that choking off money to Al Qaeda and other terrorist groups is "essentially impossible" because of inherent delays and difficulties in tracking and freezing assets in complex global financial markets, as well as the impenetrability of the informal money-transferring networks terrorist organizations use.

Instead, the commission concludes it is more productive to monitor the flow of funds to learn more about Al Qaeda, including the identities and locations of its operatives.

The report said the United States and other governments had made substantial progress in investigating and curbing the flow of terrorist funds since the Sept. 11 attacks. Even so, three years later, "the U.S. government still has not determined with any precision how much Al Qaeda raises or from whom, or how it spends its money," the report said.

Osama bin Laden's network has seen its financial resources wither as part of an international crackdown and as a consequence of the ongoing war on terrorism. Indeed, Al Qaeda's financial committee, which once carefully controlled the collection and disbursement of funds, is now either disbanded or so constrained by international scrutiny that it is unable to communicate or operate effectively, the report said.

But while Al Qaeda's funds have declined, so have its expenses. The organization no longer pays out an estimated $10 million to $20 million a year to support the Taliban, or millions more running terrorist training camps and providing funds to affiliated organizations.

Without those obligations -- the equivalent of the terrorist network's fixed costs -- it devotes its remaining resources to operations, which are relatively inexpensive, according to the report, which put a price tag on a series of Al Qaeda attacks over the years.

The 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania cost about $10,000, according to the report. The October 2002 bombing in Bali cost $20,000. As previously reported, even the Sept. 11 attacks -- a much more elaborate plot that was years in the making -- were estimated by the commission to have cost between $400,000 and $500,000.

Some informal networks that Al Qaeda used to move money before Sept. 11 have been shut down, as have many groups that provided financial support while identifying themselves as charities.

Los Angeles Times Articles