Advertisement
YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

BELIEFS

Documentary Questions the Existence of Jesus

In 'The God Who Wasn't There,' a former born-again Christian argues that Christ was a mythological figure.

August 20, 2005|Patricia Ward Biederman | Times Staff Writer

Brian Flemming's "Bat Boy: The Musical" was praised by critics but appalled some fundamentalists with its references to incest and other dark themes. Flemming's latest project is just as likely to disturb conservative Christians.

The 39-year-old Angeleno has made an hourlong documentary titled "The God Who Wasn't There." In it, the former born-again Christian argues that the biblical Jesus never lived, but is a mythological figure like Paul Bunyan.

Initially released theatrically June 17, the documentary grew out of Flemming's research for a fictional thriller-in-progress titled, "The Beast." In that film, which he hopes to release next year, a teenage Christian discovers that the Jesus she fervently believes in never existed.

"My position is that's the most likely scenario," the filmmaker said.

Asked why he chose to question Jesus' existence instead of his divinity, Flemming said: "I think that the idea that an individual could be the son of a god is already so ridiculous it doesn't need to be debunked."

To promote the movie, Flemming places it squarely in the company of other headline-making exposes: " 'Bowling for Columbine' did it to the gun culture. 'Super Size Me' did it to fast food. Now 'The God Who Wasn't There' does it to religion.... Hold on to your faith. It's in for a bumpy ride."

Made for less than $100,000, with jazzy graphics and David Byrne remixed on the soundtrack, the documentary includes a montage of images from a 1905 silent movie on the life of Christ and the 1952 miniseries "The Living Bible."

Wielding his own camera, Flemming interviews believers outside a Billy Graham event and talks with academics who argue that the Jesus of the Gospels did not live 2,000 years ago in what is now Israel.

Flemming also returns to the campus of the Sun Valley Christian school where, he said, he accepted Christ as his personal savior. The school superintendent walks out mid-interview.

If that makes the documentary sound, to believers, like the evil twin of Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ," that's fine with Flemming.

To get attention for his movie, he is mimicking Gibson, who generated word of mouth for his controversial film about the Crucifixion by screening it first for Christian groups.

Flemming is encouraging skeptics groups and others to show his movie, allowing them to keep any profits once they purchase the DVD. It goes on sale Tuesday (its website is www.thegodmovie.com).

Flemming will screen and talk about the film Sunday at 11 a.m. in the Center for Inquiry-West's Steve Allen Theater, 4773 Hollywood Blvd., Hollywood. The secular humanist organization will repeat the program at 4:30 p.m. at the Costa Mesa Community Center, 1845 Park Ave. (Admission is $6 for nonmembers, free for members.)

With his parents, the young Flemming attended a Methodist church. But, he said, his parents were concerned about violence in the Sylmar public schools and sent him to a nearby fundamentalist Christian school. There, he said, he believed his teachers when they said that God created the world in six days and other Bible-based lessons.

But those beliefs crumbled when he went to UC Irvine and began studying philosophy and science.

"I am not one of those atheists who has a big conversion story," he said. "It took me a while to call myself an atheist, because it was drummed into me that was such a bad thing to be."

What Flemming learned at a secular university convinced him that his fundamentalist teachers had "misrepresented what evolution was" and distorted other truths to bolster their Christian faith.

It is "frightening to me that children get indoctrinated in it," he said.

Chris Leland, a spokesman for the Focus on the Family Institute, an educational unit of the evangelical Christian organization, has seen the film and decries the scholarship that Flemming uses to argue against a historic Jesus.

"Some of the original premises of the film are shallowly researched," Leland said. "It ignores an enormous range of Jewish research on a person called Jesus, archeological confirmations ... as well as other external historical documents."

One of the people arguing on screen for questioning belief is neuroscientist Sam Harris, author of "The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason." An atheist, Harris praised the film for challenging what he regards as a maladaptive taboo in contemporary society -- against asking people of faith to present evidence for their contentions.

"We allow people to make the most extraordinary claims without giving evidence," Harris said. "It's considered uncivil to criticize people's religious certainties.... Whether Jesus existed or not, we need to criticize people's false certainties."

Father Thomas Rausch, a Jesuit priest and professor of theology at Loyola Marymount University in Los Angeles, has not seen the film. But, he said, "I don't know any serious scholar who questions the existence of Jesus."

Advertisement
Los Angeles Times Articles
|
|
|