THERE were lots of excellent albums during 2005, but only three brilliant ones: Bright Eyes' "I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning," Kanye West's "Late Registration" and the White Stripes' "Get Behind Me Satan."
All three are works of immense ambition and craft, and the reaction to them has been so extreme -- from near suffocating praise in one case to considerable puzzlement in another -- that you wonder about the effect of it all on their creators.
Normally, musicians speak out only after they've moved on and finished their next album, long after they've digested the reactions to the last one and come up with new music. But West, Bright Eyes' Conor Oberst and the Stripes' Jack White broke the pattern by sitting down this month -- long before they begin work on albums that they don't expect to be released until 2007 -- to answer questions about their dramatic years.
And there are lots of questions.
One shared answer: Don't let reaction to the album affect your artistic direction.
Conor Oberst
In "Wide Awake," Oberst took on the great singer-songwriter tradition of Bob Dylan with an ambition and youthful vigor that hasn't been seen since the '70s -- and critics reacted with "masterpiece" notices.
That's a heady experience for a 25-year-old on an indie label (Saddle Creek). Add to the mix that Oberst's other album this year, the more experimental rock CD titled "Digital Ash in a Digital Urn," met with far less praise.
He admits the attention and acclaim threw him off balance for a while -- one reason he did so many shows (about 150) during the year.
"I learned that it's important to stay as close to the music as possible," he said by phone from his native Omaha. "It's easy to lose track of who you are sometimes, but there is always the saving grace of getting on stage and playing your songs. That's where I always find peace."
So what now?
Will he listen to critics and stay on the folk path? Or try to prove everyone wrong by continuing in the rock vein?
"It was so strange hearing such different things about the records because we put just as much time and energy into both of them," he said. "But the experience definitely gave me some perspective.
"I realize now there is going to be some stuff we do that more people will relate to and other things that less people will relate to, and that doesn't make either better or worse. The important thing is that I and [producer Mike Mogis] feel rewarded by the work.
"The worst thing is to feel like you have to repeat yourself no matter how successful something turned out."
Oberst has nearly 20 songs at least partly written and expects to write more before finishing his new album. He wants to go into the studio in spurts, maybe even different studios to give it more varied textures than the last two.
"These records were both homogeneous in their own ways," he said. "It would be nice next time to shoot for something that's a bit more [mixed up], something that sounds like a mix tape."
Jack White
The Stripes' leader made the most dramatic change of his career in 2005 by setting down the electric guitar, the trademark sound of the Detroit blues-rock duo, in favor (mostly) of piano and other instruments to better express this album's tales of betrayal and lost idealism.
It was a marvelously powerful work that got lots of glowing reviews and already has sold more than 2 million copies worldwide, according to his management company. But the change of styles clearly confused some critics and fans, who saw the move from the guitar as a sign that White had simply run out of ideas with their limited instrumentation. Radio programmers too have been slower to embrace "Satan."
Any second thoughts on the album?
"I love it," he said by phone from New York, where he and drummer Meg White were doing TV appearances. "It's probably my second favorite after our first album, and it's Meg's favorite.
"It showed that there were all these different feelings inside me, different emotions and different styles. That told us there is still a lot more we can do as a two-piece."
What did he think, after the Stripes' years as critical darlings, to see some critics baffled by the duo's change of direction?
"Certain reactions I thought were hilarious," he said. "The New Yorker, for instance. It kept saying I should have gotten Christina Aguilera to sing on the album with me. What's that all about? I think there is this idea that there is some perversion in my brain about wanting to blow things on purpose, just to shake people up, but I never premeditate that kind of stuff.
"You can't let other people's feelings determine what you do. It never did with us, and it never will," White said. "I remember when 'Elephant' came out, people were comparing it to 'White Blood Cells' and asking where is the 'Fell in Love With a Girl'-type song. Then they got into 'Seven Nation Army' and they forgot about 'Fell in Love With the Girl.'
