YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

The uneasy allies disrupting France

April 05, 2006|K.A. Dilday | K.A. DILDAY is a France-based fellow of the Institute of Current World Affairs.

Paris — THE STREETS OF France were packed again Tuesday with protesters opposed to a controversial new law that makes it easier to fire young people from their jobs. More than 1 million people poured into the streets across the country -- including 80,000 in Paris alone -- scuffling with riot police, snarling airports and roads and prompting hundreds of arrests.

The protests have been seen by some as evidence of French idealism and by others as symbolic of French entitlement. In fact, they may be both.

But they are also, simply, French. In France, street protests are often ends in themselves; the French have a deep faith in the voice of the streets, even if it isn't always wise. Strikes, student demonstrations and immigrant rallies are all relatively common. Protesting, people say, is the national sport.

On my largely residential street in the 9th arrondissement, an economically mixed neighborhood in Paris, for instance, workers from the gas company have been busily protesting privatization outside the neighborhood office for most of the last week. They stand in small clusters during the day and at nightfall they are gone, leaving behind cigarette butts and a confetti of colored fliers. They return each morning to resume their smoking and protesting.

University students have been demonstrating in much the same way for more than a month now, but the protests have been steadily gaining strength.

When I visited the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Science Sociales, one of France's most prestigious academic institutes, I saw that the stone plaque that bears the seal of the university had been defaced; in front of the first "E" in the motto "Evolution of Human Beings," someone had taped an R.

But what exactly is this revolution of young human beings about? It is ostensibly directed against the "First Job Contract," which supporters say will help free up the labor market. The law (which technically took effect on Sunday, but is not yet being applied) allows employers to bypass strict French laws that make it difficult to fire workers once they're on the books; the idea, supported by Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin, is that companies haven't been hiring young people because they're too hard to fire. The law allows people who are 26 or younger to be fired at any time, for any reason, within two years.

The students say it isn't fair to single them out and that there are already special contracts that limit their term of employment. They don't buy De Villepin's assurances that jobs will be easier to get as a result of the new law, and they complain that they already have a hard enough time finding a job in France.

But they're only telling part of the story. It is also important to note that many French young people -- or at least many of the students who are out protesting -- opt not to work and therefore are not part of the "workforce" that will be affected by the law.

In fact, only 37.5% of French 15- to 24-year-olds participate in the workforce, a percentage that includes anyone who has a job or is unemployed and seeking one. By contrast, the portion of the workforce for the same age group is 61.1% in the U.S., 67.4% in Britain and 44.8% in Japan.

Part of the reason is that education is very important in France. There is a clear track to success, and it begins with obtaining a baccalaureate degree, which is necessary before proceeding to one of the handful of prestigious schools that ensure a prestigious career.

But there is a group of young people that enters the labor market at an early age. It is the youth from the banlieues, the coded way of describing young people of North African descent, most of whom are Muslim, and blacks. Fewer of these kids go on to a university, so they begin looking for jobs while young.

AMONG THIS group, unemployment runs at more than 40%, almost twice what it is for youth in general. Yet my interviews with them suggest that they aren't nearly as adamantly opposed to De Villepin's jobs law (although they're perfectly happy to go out and participate in the demonstrations).

For them, the status quo that the university students are fighting for isn't so appealing, and anything that might actually allow them to taste fully the fruits of the republic is welcome.

De Villepin has repeatedly said that the jobs law will help the youth in the banlieues. Azouz Begag, the minister for the promotion of equal opportunity and one of the highest-ranking people of North African descent in French politics in several decades, agrees, and he has made impassioned pleas for support of the new law in newspapers and on television.

The last march I saw against the jobs law ended in France's vast Place de la Republique. The marches have become magnets for all of the country's youth, who seem to consider them the evening's social activity regardless of how they feel about the new law.

As usual, the union workers and adults left when they completed the route and the youth remained: There were the impassioned university students who believe in the power of the streets, and the youth of the banlieues who seem to believe only in the life of the moment.

Under gray skies and a mist of rain, the two groups began a strangely tense dance, united in their dislike of the police that encircled them, alienated in their vision of the future. It is a divide that no new law or contract is likely to bridge.

Los Angeles Times Articles