YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections


Angelides Dares to Say the T-Word

Democrat in governor's race speaks of closing corporate loopholes and taxing the wealthy.

April 14, 2006|Robert Salladay | Times Staff Writer

SACRAMENTO — In an election in which the Democratic candidates for governor have more in common than in conflict, state Treasurer Phil Angelides has isolated himself with a politically hazardous, if nervy, plan: raise taxes.

No major candidate has been more public than Angelides about increasing taxes. His enthusiasm is tempered only by a focus on targeting the wealthy and corporations, not ordinary Californians, to increase public school funding and balance the state budget.

California, home of the iconic anti-tax measure Proposition 13, has a mixed record on embracing higher taxes -- and it has punished some candidates who did so. After raising the vehicle license fee -- defined by its opponents as a "car tax" -- in 2003, former Democratic Gov. Gray Davis was quickly recalled from office. Lowering it was the first act of his successor, Republican Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Angelides compares himself to previous California governors who raised taxes -- Ronald Reagan and Pat Brown, among others -- and frames his position in moral terms. In an interview, he said the seminal issue of his campaign is "whether we are going to have the guts and the will to provide our kids with the best education possible."

In the past week alone, Angelides has given three news conferences focusing on raising taxes to "fully fund education." It has drawn media attention at a critical point in his campaign -- even as opinion polls show a tightening race with state Controller Steve Westly for the Democratic nomination, he has pulled his TV ads off the air to save money for the final weeks before the June 6 primary.

Garry South, Westly's chief political consultant and a former advisor to Davis, called promoting tax increases to such an extent "beyond idiotic."

"I can't even begin to tell you how stupid that position is," South said. "If he is the Democratic nominee in November, he is toast."

Westly has said that he would consider tax increases only as a last resort.

Schwarzenegger's campaign wryly suggested that Angelides was at least being honest about his intentions.

"Steve Westly, on the other hand, appears to be hiding the ball when it comes to increasing taxes," said Matt David, a Schwarzenegger spokesman.

Schwarzenegger has consistently rejected raising taxes but has funded the state's budget shortfall with long-term borrowing. That puts a future burden on taxpayers because of the interest and principal payments on the debt.

South said Angelides was being disingenuous just by asserting that he could raise taxes, given the reluctance of Republicans in the Legislature to embrace even fee increases. Under state law, a two-thirds majority is needed to raise taxes -- requiring a handful of Republicans to agree.

In response, Angelides said he would use his political capital as governor to convince the Legislature to approve tax increases. If that didn't work, he said, he would take his case to the voters through a ballot proposition.

"If you believe in something, you have to be able to fight for it all the way," he said.

Unlike presidential candidate Walter Mondale -- who lost to President Reagan in 1984 after vowing to be honest about raising taxes -- Angelides has honed his message and segregated his targets. His language is more populist than tax-and-spend liberal.

On the campaign trail, Angelides talks about "closing corporate tax loopholes" and "asking multimillionaires to pay their fair share." He brushes close to a class warfare argument: "They may have fewer Ferraris in the short term -- but this whole state will have a better-educated workforce for the long term."

He promotes himself as a straight shooter. "Any candidate for governor has an obligation to be clear, to lay out the hard facts and specifics," he said this month.

It is a familiar theme for him: In 2003, he accused Republicans of taking a "dumbed-down approach, which is no new taxes."

That same year, he called for raising taxes on commercial properties so they would be more aligned with assessed value. In 2004, he suggested lifting the exemption on sales taxes for farm equipment. He has also proposed raising taxes on alcohol and imposing a new tax on certain services such as legal and accounting fees.

California voters are not necessarily against raising taxes on upper incomes: two years ago, voters approved a 1% tax increase on those who make more than $1 million to pay for expanding mental health services. Proposition 63 passed with nearly 54% of the vote.

Public opinion surveys also show a somewhat receptive audience thus far to Proposition 82, a June ballot initiative that would raise the tax rate on individuals making more than $400,000 and couples making more than $800,000 to fund a statewide preschool program.

Los Angeles Times Articles