YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Find out how you measure up

April 24, 2006|Shari Roan | Times Staff Writer

Scientists are changing their minds about the best way to monitor body fat. Body mass index, or BMI -- long considered the gold standard for evaluating an increased risk of health problems due to weight -- is far from a perfect measure, says Dr. Arya M. Sharma, an obesity researcher at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.

The BMI doesn't take into account the amount of muscle a person has, and is less accurate in older people, who lose muscle and bone and gain fat with age. It is also less accurate in certain ethnic groups, such as Asians, because their body fat percentage at various BMIs differs from that of Caucasians.

It also doesn't measure visceral fat, which may be more significant to overall health than knowing one's BMI.

The best way to measure visceral fat is by a CT scan, which shows the amount and location of body fat. It's not possible to do the expensive scans on everyone, however. Luckily, using a tape measure will work fine too.

Don't assume you're too fat around the middle -- or just fine -- without measuring your waist. While most overweight people have excessive visceral fat, even people whose BMI is considered normal can have an unhealthy waist circumference.

In a study published last year by University of Pittsburgh researchers, abdominal fat was linked to metabolic syndrome in older people regardless of whether they were normal weight, overweight or obese. Having more subcutaneous fat in the thighs, however, seemed to protect individuals from metabolic syndrome. To assess abdominal fat, measure either your waist or your hip-to-waist ratio.

* Waist: Measure your waist at its narrowest point as viewed from the front. That's usually at the belly button for normal-weight people. If you're overweight, measure at the point of the elbow when your arms are at your sides. Pull the tape measure snug -- no slack in the tape -- but not so tight that it's compressing your skin. Keep the tape measure parallel to the floor.

For white, black and Latino men, 40 inches or more denotes a heightened risk of health problems related to abdominal obesity. For Asian men, it's greater than 37 inches.

For white, black and Latina women, 35 inches or more denotes a heightened risk of health problems related to abdominal obesity. For Asian women, it's greater than 31 inches.

* Waist-to-hip ratio: Measure your waist as instructed above. Measure your hips at the widest part of your buttocks as viewed from the side. Divide the waist measurement by the hip measurement.

For men, a ratio of greater than 0.9 indicates an increased risk of obesity-related disease.

For women, a ratio of greater than 0.8 indicates increased risk.


Sources: American Heart Assn.; National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute.

Los Angeles Times Articles