WHEN PRESIDENT Bush sought to establish new guidelines on torture this fall, he claimed that any interrogation technique that shocks the conscience would not be allowed. Hollywood filmmakers, always eager to oppose the president, go the other way in a year-end glut of torture movies that display\o7 only \f7techniques designed to shock the conscience.
From mainstream actioners such as "Casino Royale" and "Apocalypto" to horror cut-em-ups such as "Saw III" and "Turistas" (itself a retread of 2005's breakout torture hit "Hostel"), the kind of entertainment referred to as "torture porn" combines the mise-en-scene of Abu Ghraib with screenwriting evocative of reports from Camp X-Ray.
In reviewing the torture hits, critics take pains to tell readers that these movies are somehow about our collective fears of confinement and mutilation, about confronting some kind of ultimate evil that kicks us in the crotch before it cuts off our head and sends it tumbling down the stairs, punishing us for our desires.
But if we're confronting our fears, we're sure doing it exuberantly. The ingeniously imagineered punishment devices in these movies, along with their chummy torture-chamber repartee and quick recoveries from pain and abuse, aren't so much about the fear of torture as they are about the joy of it -- and its necessity. Torture is a duty that filmmakers, like Tom Sawyer painting the fence, have convinced us is a lot of fun.
And like Tom, they've managed to fob the dirty work off on somebody else. In the real world of Guantanamo and secret prisons, the news is about people from other countries being tortured by people from this one. But in the movies it's the other way around.
The victims tend to be First World dum-dums tortured by Third World thugs, as in the Brazil-set "Turistas," in which a grab bag of English speakers from the U.S., Britain and Australia are tortured by people who speak Portuguese -- except when they deliver helpful lectures in English on fair trade.
The new James Bond, we're told, is a secret agent for today, a serious time in which the stakes are high. And, like the kids in "Turistas," he's tortured by a foreigner. So why does the torture in "Casino Royale" play like one of those frat pranks Rush Limbaugh referred to when he defended Abu Ghraib guards? Reviews of "Casino Royale" shared a certain glee over the phrase "genital torture"; critics couldn't wait to titter over it. And as Bond and Le Chiffre trade quips about itches that need scratching, they might as well be snapping towels at each other in a locker room.
