YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections


What Mr. Right doesn't read

If men won't ask for directions in a car, why would they buy an instructional book on dating?

January 06, 2006|Joann Klimkiewicz | Hartford Courant

The books come wrapped in jackets of purple and pastel pink, their titles urgent and peppered with numbers and exclamation points of the "Six Ways to Know if He's the One!" variety.

They take up substantial real estate in the self-help aisle, these tomes of dating and mating rules and lists, dispensing how-to prescriptions for every stage of the relationship cycle.

How to meet a guy. Tell if he's into you. Know if he wants to marry you.

How to spice up your marriage. Get your husband to share his feelings. Get him to scoop his dirty underwear off the floor. (Good luck.)

How to know when it's over. Tell him it's over. Get over it when it's over. How to pick yourself up, dust yourself off.

How to meet a guy.

Call it valuable counsel for the lovelorn. Call it paper-thin wisdom that capitalizes on their deepest insecurities. But there is an unmistakably strong market for these books. And they're overwhelmingly written for and purchased by women.

Industry watchers say they've seen a swell in this genre, propelled in part by the success of last year's "He's Just Not That Into You" -- the sassy cult favorite inspired by an episode of "Sex and the City" that implores women to stop making excuses for wishy-washy men and raise the bar for what they'll accept from the opposite sex.

"I've gotten a slew of books in the last couple of months," says Sarah Gold, senior reviews editor at Publishers Weekly. "They're definitely geared more toward women. I don't think any of the ones I got were specifically geared toward men."

But if it indeed takes two to tango, if on a very basic level men and women are seeking the same thing -- each other -- why are women so much more keen to study the ins and outs of dating and relationships? Where are the advice books for men? Why aren't books being written for men?

"I saw the guy who wrote ["He's Just Not That Into You"] on TV, and the interviewer asked him the same question," says Colin Mulready, 28, easing back at a corner table with some friends at the Wood-n-Tap in Hartford, Conn. "He said, 'Because I want to sell more than two books.' "

That's not far off.

According to Barnes & Noble, 80% of customers who bought books on relationships are women. Relationship books for women outsell those for men by a ratio of 4 to 1, the company reports.

"It's always a strong market. It seems there's a constantly replenishing audience for it. Depending on what stage they're at in their life, they're going back to that self-help shelf and looking for what's the newest answer, what's the latest theory," says Gary Krebs, executive publishing director of Adams Media. "Sometimes [women] may not actually know what they're seeking. There's a sense of things not feeling quite right ... a general unhappiness, and they want to figure out why that unhappiness exists and how to solve the problem."

Adams seems to have found a cushy niche in this category. Among its popular selections: "The List: 7 Ways to Tell if He's Going to Marry You -- in 30 Days or Less!" The publishing company has yet to print a guide for men. And it's not likely.

"We've basically drawn the conclusion that there isn't much of a point to it," Krebs says. "That doesn't mean men don't need books in that category, because I'm sure they do. But ... I just don't think it would work."

Oh, but there are relationship books on the shelves for the gents. A cursory search through online booksellers yields the following gem: "Make Every Girl Want You: How to Have Sex With Hot Girls (Without Even Dating Them!)"

"It's not that men don't read. It's that they're not reading what's not interesting to them. These books have to use the language they use. You wouldn't write in Japanese to someone who speaks Spanish," says relationship author Jaci Rae.

Not that she agrees with the messages in those titles. Her book "Winning Points With the Woman in Your Life One Touchdown at a Time" marries relationship advice with football lingo to explain to men the mysteries of women and the ways of a healthy relationship.

"Men are supposed to be strong. They don't need to have all these emotions involved in what they do," Rae says. "And most books that deal with relationships deal with emotions. So men have no need for them."

Authors and publishers cite a host of reasons as to why women snap up these guides in greater numbers.

For better or worse, generalization or not, women are more inclined to chat out their feelings, analyze every delicate detail of what makes relationships go wrong and go right.

"It's the sewing circle. There's this cultural thing. Women talk and they share.... That's just what we do," said Alison Lawrence, co-author of "BitterGirl: Getting Over Getting Dumped" -- a breakup survival guide based on a play by the same name. "For guys it's more: Suffer in silence, stiff upper lip, and you just get on with it," she says.

Los Angeles Times Articles