YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections


They're No. 2

Backup quarterback can be most popular guy in NFL, and he's almost certain to get a chance

September 01, 2006|Sam Farmer | Times Staff Writer

When San Francisco quarterback Alex Smith looks over his shoulder this season, he'll probably see some 320-pound beast looking to separate him from his sensibilities. But when Smith looked over his shoulder this summer, he saw something far more comforting: Trent Dilfer, his good buddy and backup, who acts as a second set of eyes and an unofficial position coach.

Dilfer, 34, who won a Super Bowl with the Baltimore Ravens in 2000, is what many people would consider the ideal backup. He's smart, competitive, experienced ... and he knows his place. He can live with carrying a clipboard on the sideline, knowing at any moment he might have to step in and take over the offense.

"A guy like that is so rare in this world," Smith said. "With so many people, it's an all-about-me attitude, kind of a cutthroat environment. Here's a guy where it's the exact opposite. It's all about the team."

Backup quarterbacks often are called the most popular athlete in town -- mostly because when things get bumpy for the starter, fans scream for his understudy.

At some point, for some reason, they usually get him.

The only starting quarterback to throw every pass for his NFL team last season was Kansas City's Trent Green. Drew Bledsoe was the only quarterback Dallas used, same goes for Eli Manning with the New York Giants, but both of those teams called on receivers or running backs to throw from time to time. The New York Jets cycled through five quarterbacks: Brooks Bollinger, Vinny Testaverde, Chad Pennington, Jay Fiedler and Kliff Kingsbury.

The quintessential backup: Matt Cassel, who backs up Tom Brady for New England.

Cassel wasn't even the starter at USC. He backed up Carson Palmer, then Matt Leinart.



Rating the Backup Quarterbacks / Sam Farmer


TEAM: Atlanta

STARTER: Michael Vick

MAIN BACKUP: Matt Schaub

Schaub, who holds nearly every passing record at Virginia, is good enough to start for several NFL teams.


TEAM: Chicago

STARTER: Rex Grossman

MAIN BACKUP: Brian Griese

The Bears made the mistake of passing on some quality backups last season. Griese has a 39-33 record as a starter.


TEAM: Jacksonville

STARTER: Byron Leftwich

MAIN BACKUP: David Garrard

At 6 feet 2, Garrard is a tad small, but he was 4-1 as a starter last season.


TEAM: San Francisco

STARTER: Alex Smith

MAIN BACKUP: Trent Dilfer

Dilfer's Super Bowl ring counts for something, even though his Baltimore team won with defense.


TEAM: Arizona

STARTER: Kurt Warner

MAIN BACKUP: Matt Leinart

Leinart looks as poised and comfortable as the experts said he'd be. If the Cardinals can protect him, there shouldn't be much of a drop-off if he's needed.


TEAM: Baltimore

STARTER: Steve McNair

MAIN BACKUP: Kyle Boller

Boller completed a career-high 58.4% of his passes last season, despite sitting out seven games because of a toe injury.


TEAM: Carolina

STARTER: Jake Delhomme

MAIN BACKUP: Chris Weinke

Weinke, who recently signed a three-year deal, knows the Panthers' offense as well as anyone.


TEAM: Cincinnati

STARTER: Carson Palmer

MAIN BACKUP: Anthony Wright

Wright has started 19 games in seven seasons and occasionally has looked very good.


TEAM: Dallas

STARTER: Drew Bledsoe


Romo hasn't attempted a pass in three seasons, but he showed this summer that he's more than adequate in a reserve role.


TEAM: Indianapolis

STARTER: Peyton Manning


Sorgi has looked good when he has gotten a chance to play. But that's almost never.


TEAM: Miami

STARTER: Daunte Culpepper

MAIN BACKUP: Joey Harrington

Things didn't work out for Harrington in Detroit, but he has the credentials to be a spot-duty NFL player.


TEAM: Philadelphia

STARTER: Donovan McNabb

MAIN BACKUP: Jeff Garcia

Once a Pro Bowl player, Garcia has fallen off the map. But he's a capable understudy.


TEAM: Pittsburgh

STARTER: Ben Roethlisberger

MAIN BACKUP: Charlie Batch

Batch won't wow anyone, but he has been an NFL starter and is generally steady under pressure.


TEAM: St. Louis

STARTER: Marc Bulger

MAIN BACKUP: Gus Frerotte

Not only does Frerotte have a ton of experience, the former Dolphins starter knows Coach Scott Linehan's system.


TEAM: Tennessee

STARTER: Billy Volek

MAIN BACKUP: Vince Young

Volek is destined to become Young's backup at some point, and he did a very good job previously behind McNair.


TEAM: Buffalo

STARTER: J.P. Losman

MAIN BACKUP: Kelly Holcomb

Both quarterbacks are good enough to deserve a chance, and bad enough to cause Bills fans to scream, "Put in the other guy!"


TEAM: Denver

STARTER: Jake Plummer


Cutler will be good down the line. The Broncos are hoping they don't have to put him in too soon.


TEAM: Detroit

STARTER: Jon Kitna


In the last two seasons with Arizona, McCown was replaced as a starter three times. Kitna is better suited to be a backup.


TEAM: Green Bay

STARTER: Brett Favre

MAIN BACKUP: Aaron Rodgers

Once viewed as the heir apparent to a legend, Rodgers was so-so in limited duty last season.


TEAM: Kansas City

STARTER: Trent Green

Los Angeles Times Articles