YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Newbery winner may have the last word

Susan Patron, surprised by controversy over her children's book, sees a bright side: rising sales.

February 24, 2007|Scott Timberg | Times Staff Writer

Susan Patron is the kind of reader who really lives books: She jokes that years before she came to work in the Los Angeles Public Library system she spent virtually all her free time in its branches. When she met the man who would become her husband, some of their early dates were at Chatterton's, the now shuttered Los Feliz bookstore.

But now this warm, cardigan-clad veteran of the city's Central Library -- a well-known and admired figure in the city's children's lit circles -- has become a kind of Henry Miller of the preteen set. Her recent Newbery Award-winning book, "The Higher Power of Lucky," aimed at readers ages 9 to 11, has been denounced by librarians, some of whom have declined to order it, all over the country. Rallying to her defense has been a collection of supporters in the press, in bookstores, and online. Barbara Walters spoke up in favor of the book on "The View," and Simon & Schuster, Patron's publisher, has fielded inquiries from David Letterman's show.

"It was very hard at first, because some of the loudest voices against it were coming from librarians," Patron, 58, said in the downtown library's cafeteria over a hot cup of tea. These are, after all, her people. She's been likened by one of them, unfavorably, to shock jock Howard Stern.

The controversy has focused on a single passage on the first page, in which the book's 10-year-old heroine, Lucky, an orphaned girl living in a tiny desert town in the Eastern Sierras, overhears a recovering alcoholic recounting his lowest moment. It came one day "when he had drunk half a gallon of rum listening to Johnny Cash all morning," and fell out of his car "when he saw a rattlesnake on the passenger seat biting his dog, Roy, on the scrotum." (Patron has said the detail was based on a real incident.)

Lucky later decides that the word "sounded medical and secret, but also important."

If only Lucky had known just how important some grownups would find the word, which as it turns out plays only the smallest part in the book. Because children's books depend heavily on librarians for sales and circulation, the outrage that has erupted on such online discussion groups as LM_Net could damage the book's reach. The Newbery is awarded by the Assn. for Library Service to Children, a division of the American Library Assn. But some librarians and teachers have said they find the book vulgar, some said they were uncomfortable reading the word aloud, and others have said they don't want calls from angry parents. Patron herself, meanwhile, has received "pretty nasty" e-mails.

Patron, a former branch children's librarian who's in charge of assembling children's materials for the L.A. system, can take the long view on the history of controversial children's books. She was surprised by the outcry; her French-born husband was, she said, "nonplused."

"I think this came up because it's on Page 1," said Patron, "and because it's won this major award. For people who don't like to read this whole book, but just to object to a word, I handed it to them, you know? They didn't have to go further."

Over the book's 134 pages, Lucky worries that her guardian will move back to her native France, catches bugs, consorts with her dog HMS Beagle and her friend Lincoln, who is a member of the International Guild of Knot Tyers. To an adult eye, it mostly comes off as pretty sweet and innocent -- a typical child's journey.

"She's trying to grow up," said Patron, "trying to find out what she needs to be an adult."

Young Adult, or "YA," books, which are typically aimed at readers 11 or 12 and older, often cover controversial ground, dealing with sexuality, painful coming-of-age issues and world crises. But "Lucky" is more of a children's book.

Here on Patron's home turf of Los Angeles, the controversy hasn't caught fire.

"I truthfully don't think it will affect our sales here," Sharon Hearn, owner of Children's Book World in West L.A., said of the uproar. "I don't think our customers object to the mention of a part of the anatomy."

Hearn's store did a book signing with Patron when "Lucky" came out in November with a print run of 10,000. "I wouldn't hesitate to recommend that book," Hearn said. "It's a very well written, engaging story about a universal theme: a girl wanting to have a secure home."

Local school librarians support Patron, said Carolyn Gill, a librarian at Palms Middle School, who called Patron "a guru as far as knowing books and children. She's the world's nicest person. She's not flip; she's sincere."

Kerry Slattery, manager of Skylight Books, said she had heard no complaints from customers about the book but was herself shocked by the controversy. "When I read this book, before it won the Newbery Award, I thought it was just wonderful. It's very powerful, but not because of anything having to do with the word 'scrotum.' "

Los Angeles Times Articles