YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections


Germany is feeling sub-prime fallout

Taxpayers could be on the hook for half the estimated $69 billion in bank losses.

June 04, 2008|Kim Murphy | Times Staff Writer

DRESDEN, GERMANY — When the Berlin Wall fell and start-up businesses began sprouting across eastern Germany, former communists who saw themselves as budding entrepreneurs were many, but banks ready to lend them money at affordable rates were few.

Enter Germany's state banks, locally run institutions whose board members were often mayors, local finance ministers and small-town bankers who cared as much about what a business brought to the community as its bottom line. Because these banks' assets were guaranteed by the state, their loans came cheaper than private banks could offer.

Here in the eastern state of Saxony, loans from community savings banks and the regional government bank, SachsenLB, helped fuel the region's dynamic biotech industry, new Porsche and BMW plants and the expansion of the airport at Leipzig. Such projects helped Saxony achieve the highest economic growth rates in depressed eastern Germany.

But when the state banks were forced by the European Union to compete on even terms with their commercial counterparts, several over the last few years turned to the U.S. sub-prime market for quick profits. Now, SachsenLB has become one of the European banks with the greatest exposure to sub-prime losses, as a fraction of total assets.

In a sobering tale of old-fashioned community banking's clash with the complexities of modern international finance, the bank's financial woes led to the resignation last month of Saxony Gov. Georg Milbradt. Saxon taxpayers, meanwhile, have been left holding the bag for potential losses of as much as $4.2 billion -- 17% of the state budget.

SachsenLB is among several state-owned German banks that have foundered in a meltdown that Germany's top industry regulator said fell just short of "the worst financial crisis since 1931."

Most other analysts hurried to say it wasn't that bad. But estimates of the potential losses have reached as high as $69 billion, with taxpayers liable for nearly half that amount, under some scenarios.

Private banks haven't been immune. Deutsche Bank announced in April a pretax first-quarter loss of $391 million after write-downs of $4.16 billion.

The first bank to take a hit in Germany's sub-prime banking crisis, IKB Deutsche Industriebank, a Dusseldorf-based commercial lender specializing in loans to small and medium-size businesses and in real estate finance, has so far received a bailout package exceeding $13 billion, including more than $3 billion from the public purse.

"Everyone has talked about the banking losses, but it could be even more interesting to look at the social consequences of the crisis," said Jorg Rocholl, associate professor at Berlin's European School of Management and Technology. "In Saxony you are talking about a guarantee of almost 3 billion euros to bail out a bank -- money which could have been used in financing schools, hospitals."

Germany's second-biggest state-owned bank, Munich-based BayernLB, revealed in April that fallout from the U.S. housing market crisis had cost it $6.6 billion. BayernLB, like most of the regional state banks known as landesbanken, is owned jointly by the state of Bavaria and the state's association of savings banks.

WestLB, the third-biggest state-owned bank, in the state of North Rhine-Westphalia, in April reported 2007 losses of $2.5 billion, nearly $925 million more than the bank was predicting a few months earlier. Bank executives said they would lay off nearly a quarter of the workforce and its CEO stepped down.

Yet the tempest in the banking industry so far has not hit the wider economy. Germany posted its highest quarter-on-quarter growth rate in 12 years in the first quarter of this year, with a gross domestic product boost of 1.5%.

Germany's banking industry has always been more diffuse than its European peers, in part because of the presence of so many state banks. These take the form of about 400 community savings banks -- down from nearly 2,000 a few years ago -- and bigger regional landesbanken that originally were fixed in many of Germany's 16 states as the equivalent of state central banks.

Thus, although institutions such as Deutsche Bank may come to mind when people think of German banks, the market share of big commercial banks is low -- barely 20% for Germany's five biggest banks.

State banks have been especially prevalent in eastern Germany, where citizens in the communist era used them as a repository for their savings and turned naturally to them for loans when it came time to set up private businesses.

The state banks also offered a local ear: Saxony's finance minister chairs SachsenLB's board, which also includes four county politicians, the mayors of Dresden and Leipzig, the state economics minister, four union representatives, two state lawmakers and representatives of three state-owned community banks.

Los Angeles Times Articles