A Santa Monica middle school teacher who allegedly molested five of his female students was investigated by police, but not charged, in connection with the same crime in 2006, officials said Wednesday.
"There was a lack of evidence at the time to file charges," said Jane Robison, spokeswoman for the Los Angeles County district attorney's office. "But based on new allegations, new victims and more evidence, sufficient evidence was developed to include the previous alleged victim" in this case.
Lincoln Middle School teacher Thomas Arthur Beltran, 60, pleaded not guilty Tuesday to 14 felony counts of sexual molestation, including eight counts of a lewd act on a child, three counts of continuous sexual abuse and three counts of sexual penetration with a foreign object on a child under 14.
According to court documents, the alleged abuse of the students took place between Dec. 1, 2004, and April 30 of this year. Police said at least one of the alleged molestations had been recorded on a videotape obtained in a search during the investigation.
On Wednesday, officials of the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District released a letter dated March 14, 2006, written by then-Principal Kathy Scott to police detailing her response to the earlier complaint. Police gave district officials a copy of the letter this week, said Mike Matthews, district assistant superintendent for human resources.
The letter states that a female student reported to a school official that she "felt uncomfortable being in Mr. Beltran's class because of the way he touched her." Scott's response was to have her removed from the class and to talk to Beltran about the incident, the letter says.
Beltran "was shocked at the accusation and was upset that his actions had been misinterpreted as inappropriate," according to the letter. Scott wrote that the teacher was warned "not to touch any of the female students in his class in order to protect himself from any further misinterpretation."
Santa Monica police told district officials Tuesday there had been insufficient evidence after an investigation to pursue a criminal case against Beltran. "The letter was not in the teacher's personnel file," Matthews said. "Obviously, the principal and the police were talking. . . . I've examined the entire personnel file and there is no other complaint in there against him."
Matthews said the district was trying to reach Scott. A woman who answered the phone at Scott's office Wednesday said she had no comment.
