YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Isotope shortage means a healthcare crisis

The radioisotope is needed to scan for heart disease and cancer. Two nuclear reactors that produce it have been shut down, severely limiting the supply, and alternatives are scant.

August 09, 2009|Thomas H. Maugh II

The abrupt shutdown of two aging nuclear reactors that produce a radioisotope widely used in medical imaging has forced physicians in the U.S. and abroad into a crisis, requiring them to postpone or cancel necessary scans for heart disease and cancer, or turn to alternative tests that are not as accurate, take longer and expose patients to higher doses of radiation.

Because of limits on testing produced by the shortage, some patients will undergo heart or cancer surgeries that could have been prevented by imaging, and others will miss needed surgeries because of the lack of testing, said Dr. Michael Graham of the University of Iowa, president of SNM, formerly the Society of Nuclear Medicine. "It's possible that some deaths could occur," he said.

Private companies and government agencies in the U.S. and Canada are looking at new sources of the radioisotope, including the possibility of building new reactors and modifying existing research reactors, but any long-term solution is at least two to three years in the future, experts agree.

The situation is complicated by efforts by the U.S. government, the sole provider of the uranium used in the reactors, to shift to low-enriched uranium from the high-enriched fuel that is now used. Government officials fear that terrorists theoretically could divert the high-enriched form to the construction of bombs.

The shortage "is one of the greatest threats to our profession of modern times," said radiologist Robert W. Atcher of the University of New Mexico, last year's president of SNM.

The focus of this shortage is a short-lived radioisotope that most patients have probably never heard of -- technetium-99m, the "m" standing for metastable. With a half-life of only six hours, the isotope allows physicians to examine bones and blood flow, among other things, then quickly disappears from the body, minimizing the dose of radiation received by the patient. Because of its short half-life, the isotope cannot be stockpiled and must be used within a day or two after it is produced.

Every day of the year, nearly 55,000 Americans and tens of thousands of patients in other countries undergo nuclear medicine tests -- such as checking for the spread of cancer to the bones or monitoring the flow of blood through the heart -- most of them using technetium-99m. The radioisotope is attached to chemicals that allow it to bind to specific sites in the body, where it emits gamma rays that can be used to produce an image of the area.

The technetium-99m used in these tests is produced in five reactors around the world, all of them at least 45 years old and none of them in the United States.

Three times within the last 18 months, the National Research Universal reactor in Chalk River, Canada, which normally supplies about a third of U.S. technetium-99m demand, has shut down because of leaks of radioactive tritium-contaminated water. On May 14, it shut down for the third time, and it will not reopen until the end of the year. Some experts suspect it will never reopen if a containment vessel is badly corroded.

Even if it reopens, its long-term prospects are not good. Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper said this year that the country would be out of the radioisotope business by 2016 because of repeated failures to bring a new reactor online. "We can't spend hundreds of millions of dollars and never produce an isotope," he said.

Last month, the Petten nuclear reactor in the Netherlands, which supplies half the U.S. requirement, shut down for a month for routine maintenance and it is expected to close for at least three months next year for repairs.

Radiologists are already feeling the effects. About 91% have suffered shortages of some sort, according to SNM's Graham.

"We have still been able to do our studies, although some scans must often be significantly delayed for several weeks due to the limited, sporadic supply of isotope," said Dr. J. Martin Hogan, chief of diagnostic radiology and imaging services at City of Hope National Medical Center in Duarte.

"There is no question that it is delaying tests," added Dr. Johannes Czernin, chief of nuclear medicine at UCLA's Ronald Reagan Medical Center. "We have to reschedule patients frequently because we never know how much of the technetium we will get. . . . It is not yet at the point where it is an emergency disaster, but it makes life much more difficult."

The shortage is also straining hospital finances.

When a shipment does come in, some hospitals are scheduling tests far into the evening and on weekends to use up the technetium before it disintegrates -- frazzling the nerves of some technicians and boosting overtime costs.

The cost of the radioisotope itself has also gone up, by at least 20% to 30%, according to Dr. Marcelo F. Di Carli, chief of nuclear medicine at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston. "That's overhead we are absorbing because reimbursement is fixed."

Los Angeles Times Articles