Butter, flour, sugar and a little bit of salt. There's not much that's simpler than a shortbread. But for those of us who love to bake, it's the perfect kind of recipe. Despite being made from a limited number of inexpensive ingredients, the dough can be transformed into a seemingly endless number of variations. It's also ridiculously easy to make.
It's the purity of the flavors that makes shortbread so wonderful. There are no leaveners such as baking soda or baking powder to give it off flavors. There's not even any vanilla extract. You can really taste even minor changes made to the recipe, whether it's experimenting with different sugars and flours or sprinkling a little of this and that into the dough.
The earliest shortbreads were lighter on the butter than ones made today and often included ground oats, the staple grain in 16th century Scotland, rather than wheat flour. Modern recipes typically have more sugar. When combined with a generous amount of butter, this gives you the "short" (as in crumbly) namesake texture.
Shortbread is one of those recipes that is so easy you're sure you've forgotten something when you close the oven door.
All you really need to remember is to place the butter in a bowl to soften at room temperature for two hours before you want to make the cookies. It should be completely softened, though not melted. And be sure to beat in the sugar and salt until just combined (overwhipping incorporates air into the dough, which can cause the shortbread to buckle as it bakes). Quickly blend in the flour, and that's it.
Give it shape
Next, decide what shape cookie you want. A round cake pan will lightly steam the dough, yielding a slightly chewier, wedge-shaped shortbread; dough that's shaped on a baking sheet gives you classic crispy rectangles. Press the dough into the cake pan or roll it out into a rectangle. You'll need to prick it all over with a fork to release steam while baking.
For the easiest variations, follow the basic recipe and fold in chopped candied ginger, dried cherries, toasted nuts or whatever you like just before baking. Add a tablespoon of fresh rosemary or thyme for a savory-sweet touch. Cut the amount down to a teaspoon if you're using dried herbs or spices. Cracked pepper or cinnamon shortbreads are nice alternatives to the typical afternoon caffeine-break cookie. How about Chinese five-spice powder?
When butter is the main ingredient, splurging on artisan varieties seems like a good idea. But everyday unsalted butter works great, and it's inexpensive enough for guilt-free experimenting. For a more complex, nutty flavor, try brown butter shortbread. Cook the butter over medium heat until it turns a dark amber color, but be careful not to burn it. You could strain out the brown bits if you don't want little specks in your shortbread, but I like to leave them in for the added flavor. Chill the butter for an hour until it is firm enough to cream and follow your basic recipe as usual.
Flour will alter texture more than the flavor. Everyday all-purpose flour is best for that crispy-crumbly classic shortbread. You can also substitute three-fourths cup of whole-wheat flour for the same amount of all-purpose. The coarser texture of wheat flour, not always a good marriage with delicate pastries, works well because it complements shortbread's already solid structure. Slather with jam, and breakfast is served.
Mix and match
For a really tender crumb, try substituting a small amount of rice flour for the all-purpose. The lower gluten content gives you a delicate texture, but half a cup is plenty. Add more and you'll taste a slight graininess.
My favorite flour substitution is regular rolled oats that I've ground into a fine powder. The only trick is chilling the dough -- this one is shaped into logs like a sugar cookie -- for several hours before slicing it into rounds. The dough is stickier than most, but it's sliced so thin you don't need to prick the cookies to release the steam. It has quite a powerful buttery, toasted oat flavor for such a simple, delicate little cookie.
Sugar affects both flavor and texture, so it's particularly fun to experiment with. Substitute light brown sugar for the granulated and the shortbread gets all caramel-y and slightly chewy from the molasses in the sugar. It's hard not to take another bite just to make sure there's nothing else in there but brown sugar.
With powdered sugar, you'll get a delicate melt-in-your-mouth cookie. Increase the amount of sugar in the recipe by 25% to get the same sweetness because, ounce for ounce, powdered sugar is not as dense as granulated sugar.