Orange County Sheriff Sandra Hutchens appeared one more time Tuesday before an overflowing crowd at a Board of Supervisors meeting to explain her stance on concealed-weapons permits and why she will revoke some of the ones issued under her predecessor.
But her explanation did not satisfy the permit advocates -- including representatives of the National Rifle Assn. -- nor the supervisors. Many of the speakers called for the board to take a no-confidence vote on her management and for Hutchens to resign.
The dispute stems from permits issued by former Sheriff Michael S. Carona, convicted last month of felony witness tampering. As part of the case against him, the government alleged that Carona gave the permits to friends and campaign supporters, regardless of whether they proved they needed to carry a concealed weapon.
It was Hutchens' third appearance before the board on the issue, which has devolved to include allegations of spying and intimidation, mocking text messages sent among sheriff's officials and a battle over ownership of the board's security recordings.
While at previous meetings, Hutchens -- who was criticized for a heavy-handed sheriff's presence at a meeting last month -- appeared in dress uniform; this time she and others in her staff wore civilian clothing.
Hutchens renewed her pledge to enforce the law regarding concealed weapons, despite the opposition of more than 100 people in the audience.
"The fact is, there is a law in California prohibiting a concealed weapon, and I cannot change that," she told the board. "I believe I have taken a common-sense approach to good cause, that you must demonstrate a greater risk than the rest of the general population."
The department sent 423 people -- out of 999 permit holders -- "intent to revoke" notices in October and gave them the chance to prove their need to carry a concealed weapon. If an explanation is deemed invalid, then the permit will be revoked. No date has been set for that action.
Those concerned that their reasons might be deemed invalid can choose to have their permit expire early instead of seeking a renewal, Hutchens said, which would not taint their Department of Justice record. She said she worked with the California Department of Justice to allow that alternative because of concerns raised by people at a previous meeting.
But Supervisors Chris Norby and Janet Nguyen said that such a choice is essentially coercion.
