YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Villaraigosa's future, once bright, now tarnished

Mayor enters his second term with tepid support. Many feel that the city is on the wrong track and oppose any hopes for governor's office, poll finds.

June 21, 2009|Phil Willon

Days from the start of his second term, Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa has earned tepid job approval ratings from city voters, and a plurality opposes his entrance into the upcoming race for governor, according to a new Los Angeles Times poll.

Los Angeles' brooding electorate, battered by job losses and home foreclosures that rise above national and state trends, feels strongly that the city is on the wrong track. And almost half believes the city needs to move in a direction different from that charted by Villaraigosa, rebuking the policies of a mayor they reelected a little more than three months ago.

Although they consider the city's budget deficit an urgent problem, voters steadfastly oppose raising taxes or fees to stem the deepening fiscal crisis. Even the notion of increasing taxes to improve fire protection, a comparatively easy sell in wildfire-prone Southern California, was rejected handily.

Villaraigosa received a favorable job approval rating from 55% of the registered voters surveyed. The showing is statistically equivalent to the vote he won in the city's March election against a field of little-known and underfunded candidates. He officially begins his second term July 1.

For Villaraigosa, who casts himself as a unifying political force in the mold of five-term Mayor Tom Bradley, the survey also indicated some fraying in the broad ethnic coalition that carried him into office in 2005. Almost three-fourths of Latino voters gave the mayor high marks, as did almost two out of three African Americans, but a narrow plurality of white voters gave him negative grades.

The city's precipitous drop in crime won Villaraigosa his highest praise -- he received a 69% approval rating on handling crime. Voters also approved of his efforts to make Los Angeles a more environmentally friendly city, but scorched him on the city's budget deficit and the quality of the public schools, which ranked higher among their top concerns.

"I've actually been impressed with some of the things they've done with crime, to bring crime down. I've also been impressed because he's been so prolific. . . . He's all over town," Christopher Knudsen of Van Nuys, an unemployed recruiter for financial firms, said in a follow-up interview.

Michael Ortega of Harbor City, who was among the respondents unhappy with the mayor's tenure, said Villaraigosa appears to be more concerned about furthering his political career than serving the people of Los Angeles.

"He's never going to be focused on the business at hand. To run for governor, you have to traverse the state . . . so he won't even be around," said Ortega, 58, a retired Social Security Administration worker. "I've never trusted the guy."

Ortega said his doubts about Villaraigosa deepened after the mayor acknowledged his extramarital affair with a local newscaster, which led to the breakup of his 20-year marriage. However, most of those surveyed -- 70% -- dismissed the affair, saying it would have no effect on whether they vote for Villaraigosa in the future.

The Los Angeles Times survey was conducted by the Democratic polling firm of Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research in conjunction with Public Opinion Strategies, which surveys for Republican candidates. The findings are based on a citywide telephone survey of 1,500 registered voters conducted from June 10 to June 16. The survey has a margin of error of 2.6 percentage points in either direction.

The poll was taken as Villaraigosa not only prepares to begin his final term as mayor, but also comes to a decision on whether to run for governor in 2010. Those close to the process have said they expect a public announcement soon.

Given the nation's economic upheaval and the overall anger that voters harbor as a result, Villaraigosa's 55% job approval rating appears "acceptable," said pollster Stanley Greenberg, one of the poll supervisors. Still, he said, it's clear that Los Angeles voters are not happy with his policies.

"He's going into this term with people very distraught with the direction of the city," Greenberg said. "He's not coming with a big wind at this back. People want something new from him."

Villaraigosa's prospects as a possible gubernatorial candidate, a role that seemed almost preordained after his celebrated 2005 election as Los Angeles' first Latino mayor in more than a century, also appear to be vulnerable in a city that should be the 56-year-old politician's strongest base of support.

Among Los Angeles Democrats, Villaraigosa would only narrowly defeat state Atty. Gen. Jerry Brown if the Democratic gubernatorial primary were held today, the survey found.

According to the poll, 38% picked Villaraigosa compared with 32% for former Gov. Brown. San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom registered a distant 13%. Newsom has announced his candidacy, while Brown, like Villaraigosa, has demurred when asked his plans.

Los Angeles Times Articles