Directed by noted documentarian Johnny Symons, whose works include several explorations of gay issues, the point of view of "Ask Not" is not in doubt.
Still, it is not preachy or unfair to the other side. Gen. Colin L. Powell and then-Sen. Sam Nunn are shown in congressional hearings during the Clinton years arguing against permitting homosexuals to serve openly.
At the time, Powell was chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Nunn was chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee. Neither comes off as a homophobe or as retrograde.
Nunn says his views are shaped by "prudence, not prejudice." Powell says that "open homosexuality is incompatible" with military service.
"Ask Not" would have been stronger if it had reported whether Powell and Nunn had modified their views over the years -- as much of the U.S. population has. More interviews with women veterans would also have been good.
One of the strongest points made by "Ask Not" is that opinion within the military has changed dramatically since 1993, when "don't ask, don't tell" was adopted. Now, nearly three-quarters of military personnel say they would be comfortable with serving beside gays.
The numbers suggest that the rank and file -- consisting mostly of a younger generation -- is ready for change even if the generals and admirals, of an older, socially conservative generation, are not.
"Ask Not" is not the final word on the issue of gays in the military. There will be other works of journalism as the debate heats up in Washington and nationwide.
But it is a strong, serious effort at mixing a discussion of civil rights and a look at Americans forced to choose between love for their country and love for another human being.
--
tony.perry@latimes.com
--
'Independent Lens: Ask Not'
Where: KCET
When: 10 tonight
Rating: TV-PG-L (may be unsuitable for young children, with an advisory for coarse language)
