YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Economic 'recovery' leaves jobs behind

Labor-saving technology, competition from skilled foreign workers and a debt hangover make it tough for the U.S. economy to create jobs.

June 04, 2011|By Don Lee, Los Angeles Times
  • A job seeker fills out an application at a McDonald's restaurant in midtown New York. A host of factors, including new labor-saving technology, are adding up to a weak "jobless recovery" from the recession.
A job seeker fills out an application at a McDonald's restaurant in… (Don Emmert / AFP/Getty Images )

Reporting from Washington — Still limping two years after officially emerging from the recession and buffeted by a new wave of bad news, the U.S. economy is struggling with problems that run far deeper than higher oil prices, the European debt crisis or auto industry slowdown stemming from the Japanese earthquake and tsunami.

Serious as those problems are, what's crippling the job market and chilling recovery on almost every front is a confluence of factors that economists and business leaders say are fundamentally reshaping the economic landscape in which Americans live and work.

Taken together, these factors have created a vicious circle: Incomes of average families are barely growing, even as many struggle with heavy debts left over from the boom times. That in turn has curbed consumer spending power. And businesses, seeing little chance for a surge in sales, have had little reason to expand — neither hiring more workers nor paying their existing workers more.

"One argument is that this phenomenon [of poor job growth] is cyclical: We had the mother of all recessions after a near-death experience, and what we're seeing is just that when you get hit that hard, it takes longer to recover, but that there's nothing abnormal," said Michael Spence, a Nobel economics laureate who teaches at New York University's Stern School of Business.

"I don't believe that's right," he said. "The employment problem is new. I think everybody has to admit that. However we did it [in the past], we didn't really have a major employment problem until now."

And without more jobs and greater consumer spending power, it's hard to see how the U.S. economy can regain its old vigor.

The first big change behind this economically crippling cycle is advances in technology — especially computers and other information technology. Companies are increasingly able to maintain or even expand production without adding workers. That's one reason the country is going through a "jobless recovery."

The process has been underway for decades, but it appears to have accelerated. In the last two years, U.S. companies have spent billions of dollars on new equipment, but unemployment has remained near 10% and the economy has replaced only 1.8 million of the 8.7 million jobs lost between 2007 and 2009, when the recession technically ended.

The second factor that spells deep-rooted trouble for the U.S. economy is a dramatic change in the nature of foreign competition.

In the past, emerging nations such as India, China and South Korea once lured U.S. jobs offshore primarily because their workers — while relatively unskilled — were paid only a fraction of what American workers got.

Today, those countries are producing millions of well-educated workers, not just engineers and computer scientists, but medical researchers, financial experts and even lawyers who compete with U.S. workers who previously seemed immune to offshore competition.

And their expanding markets have attracted one American company after another. From 1999 through 2009, U.S. multinational firms added 2.4 million employees overseas while cutting their domestic staffing by 2.9 million, according to the Commerce Department. And these figures don't include outsourcing of jobs to non-U.S. companies abroad.

At technology service providers such as Computer Sciences Corp., plans to shift operations to India and other lower-cost centers are part of the boilerplate language in their annual reports. The company's revenue held steady last year, but it still managed to trim 3,000 workers from its global payroll of 94,000 in the 12 months ended in March — with some of the layoffs coming at various U.S. locations.

Advancing technology also has diminished the need for many kinds of skilled workers, especially in the middle levels where a majority of workers is found.

A year ago, Frank Goodnight, 63, dug deep into his pockets and bought a digital press for his 37-year-old printing company in Salisbury, N.C. Normally, he said, presses require two people to operate.

"This new one — half a person," he said. "The press operator now wears dress clothes to work every day."

A broad measure of productivity meant to capture the effects of technology change and labor at service and manufacturing firms showed that it rose 3.2% last year — the highest since the index was designed in 1987. That's faster than the economic output last year, meaning businesses didn't need to add much staff to meet increased orders.

The final major factor in the new economic landscape is the huge debt burden left over from the recession — in housing, consumer credit and government spending — that acts as a massive drag on the economy. Worry about the deficit also is preventing the federal government from continuing the kinds of stimulus programs put in place right after the recession began.

Los Angeles Times Articles