YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections


Automakers leave nothing to spare

More cars are selling without an extra tire, but the alternatives don't fix a flat as well.

June 20, 2011|Jerry Hirsch

That spare tire in your trunk may be going the way of the typewriter and transistor radio.

Automakers are selling more cars without an extra wheel to trim weight, boost gas mileage and shave a few bucks off their costs.

What happens if you get a flat? Some manufacturers equip cars with run-flat tires, while others are putting flat repair kits in the trunk.

Both alternatives have drawbacks, and many motorists say the trend is unsettling.

"I like the security of having a spare. It gives you peace of mind," said Mary Beth Wasmer of Baltimore.

Wasmer said she probably would have passed on the used BMW 335 she bought three months ago if the dealer had said it didn't have a spare -- something she discovered for herself.

For The Record
Los Angeles Times Tuesday, June 21, 2011 Home Edition Main News Part A Page 4 News Desk 1 inches; 36 words Type of Material: Correction
Spare tires: An article in the June 20 Section A about automakers doing away with spare tires gave an incorrect first name for the director of vehicle testing at He is Dan Edmunds, not Don.

"I couldn't find it," she said. "I opened the trunk, I looked underneath and there was no spare or even a compartment to put one in."

Still, the trend is gaining traction. A few years ago virtually all new vehicles came with spares, but last month about 13% of the more than 1 million vehicles sold in the U.S. did not offer an extra tire as standard equipment, according to a Times review of vehicle specifications and sales data. Spare tires are not required by federal regulators because they are not considered an essential safety feature.

The no-spare club includes the Hyundai Elantra and Chevrolet's Cruze and Malibu, three of America's top-selling sedans. Buick's 2012 Regal GS and upcoming hybrid versions of its Regal and LaCrosse sedans will be sans spare, as will some versions of next year's Kia Optima.

Automakers save money by selling cars with four tires instead of five, and the weight savings helps them boost vehicle gas mileage.

Adding even a 10th of a mile of efficiency to their federal fuel economy tests might allow automakers to reach a number such as 19.5 mpg on a vehicle, which they can then round up to 20 mpg on the window sticker.

"Manufacturers do a lot of little things to squeeze more of the last bits of toothpaste out of the tube. Weight reduction is just one of them, and spare tires are a tempting target," said Don Edmunds, director of vehicle testing for auto information company

Then too, fewer motorists have the need to change tires anymore. Technical improvements have made flats less likely, and when they do occur, drivers increasingly rely on roadside assistance services to take care of the problem.

"All manufacturers are looking at this," said Alan Batey, U.S. vice president of Chevrolet sales and service. "This is one opportunity to get weight out of vehicles and make them more fuel efficient.... It will take some time for people to understand this technology."

Chevrolet has been among the most aggressive of the major brands when it comes to scuttling the spare. The tire inflator kit in the Cruze sheds 26 pounds of spare tire and hardware and provides more trunk space.

Hyundai said ditching the spare saves it about $22 a vehicle. That adds up to about $4.4 million on the 200,000 Elantras it expects to sell this year.

Like Chevy and Buick, Hyundai sells cars with tire inflation kits. These consist of a can of sealant that is injected through the valve stem, plugging the puncture, and an electric pump to reinflate the tire.

It's not as good as having an extra tire. The sealant kits "work only if you have a simple puncture in the tread of the tire. And if you use it, it is only a temporary fix," said Eugene Petersen, the tire expert for Consumer Reports magazine.

Petersen said the sealant kits don't work for a tire that is shredded or suffers a complete blowout, and cannot correct the type of sidewall damage that commonly occurs to low-profile tires driven over pothole-strewn roads. Such damage could leave drivers stranded by the road, waiting for a tow.

More expensive cars -- including nearly the entire BMW lineup -- are forsaking spare tires for run-flat tires, which can be driven at moderate speeds for 50 miles or so with a puncture.

Petersen said there's less risk of being stranded by punctures in run-flat tires because they are built with reinforcement that can support the weight of a car. But run-flat tires are still not a perfect solution. "We hear a lot of complaints about noise, tread life and expense," he said.

The Continental run-flat tires that come standard on the BMW 328 sedan cost about $190 each at Southern California tire stores but are typically special-order items. The standard version of the Continental tire is about $50 less and is more widely stocked.

Improved technology, of course, means that many motorists will never experience a tire blowout.

In addition to improved tires, tire pressure monitoring systems now come standard on vehicles, warning drivers of low air pressure, leaks and punctures. That prompts people to get tires fixed before damage occurs that can cause a blowout.

"People see the light come on, they pump their tires up and they get them fixed," and that's probably contributed to a gradual decline in service calls for flats, Edmunds said.

Los Angeles Times Articles