YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Critic's Notebook: Twisting a tune to suit you, the listener

Wildly inventive apps open up the sonic possibilities to music fans. Loop, mash and re-imagine a song, then share with friends. It's like karaoke, only better.

November 27, 2011|By Randall Roberts, Los Angeles Times Pop Music Critic
  • The two-turntables-and-a-mixer app Djay turns the mechanics of Djing on its head.
The two-turntables-and-a-mixer app Djay turns the mechanics of Djing… (Adam Caira / Los Angeles…)

A few weeks ago during his concert at the El Rey Theatre, young R&B singer Frank Ocean stood alone in front of a mike onstage while a big image of a solar eclipse shone behind him. He was in the middle of his "American Wedding," which isn't really his song per se but him crooning new lyrics over the music of the Eagles' classic L.A. snapshot "Hotel California."

He moved through his updated verses, a wonderful yarn about marriage and divorce, as the moon passed across the sun behind him and the song made its way toward that epic Don Felder and Joe Walsh tag-team guitar solo. And when it arrived, the image on the screen cut to the video game Guitar Hero, where an avatar band also was jamming on "Hotel California." Ocean grabbed a toy guitar from a roadie, turned to face the game, struck a pose and played along, nailing each note while twisting his body like Jimi Hendrix. (He ended up with 350,000 points.)

It was a striking, witty move, one that acknowledged the karaoke-esque nature of his (unlicensed) appropriation. But at the same time, Ocean was, intentionally or not, implicitly messing with the distinction between performer and fan, a line that's becoming increasingly blurred as speedy computer processors enable gaming systems, smart phones and iPads the ability to generate new ways not only to digest music but also to interact with it: fans as active participants in the evolution of artistic ideas — social creativity.

Guitar Hero is old news by now, but in its wake have arrived ever more sophisticated and intuitive applications that point toward a grand shift in how we absorb, play — and increasingly play with — music. A few of the hundreds of music-related apps (excluding those that act as instruments, which is a whole other realm of wonder) suggest the breadth of the offerings, some borderline visionary, some playful, others silly. They range from full-length album re-imaginings to digital DJ tools that open the entire recorded library to cut-and-paste, four- and eight-bar looping; from quirky single-song apps that offer time-killing games to karaoke challenges and music trivia quizzes.

The most visionary recent release is also the most acclaimed: Icelandic experimental chanteuse Björk's "Biophilia" iPad album, which features a different app for each of the songs and cracks them open one by one to shed light into her music and art by allowing listeners active roles in examining them. The app for the song "Solstice," for example, is a total trip: She and her team of designers have basically created a new musical instrument on the iPad featuring orbiting sonic circles spinning in space that can be manipulated, tuned and played by increasing and decreasing the speed of the orbit, the tone of the note being played and the quantity of sounds.

It sounds way more complicated and way less beautiful than it is — as much a visual creation as an aural one. If you just want to hear the song, of course, you can do that; if you're curious about reading the song's written score, hit a button and the notation appears to accompany the music. But if you want to dig into the nuts and bolts of the compositions and rework them, Björk's work enables it.

Best, the "Solstice" app, as with the others on "Biophilia," allows users to record the music they make, save it, share it with friends and, in the process, better understand the ways in which Björk's voice and music can be re-imagined from within. Perhaps most telling, though, is how much better the apps and the visual representations of the music have been received than the music-only compact disc release. Musically, "Biophilia" found Björk stuck in the same stylistic rut she's been in for the last few releases, making typically atypical experimental electronic music. Compared with the visual feast of the interactive release, the static version of "Biophilia" seems stunted.

This truth, in fact, reveals a danger of combining high-tech visual programming with music: Experiencing a song as a singular sensual moment, getting lost inside your head — getting lost in music — is a sublime feeling, one that necessitates blocking out the other four senses. What gets lost by combining organized sound with organized interactivity?

It depends on the product (and let's face it, this new world is as much about monetization as it is art). Little suffers in the translation to Sir Mix A Lot's Baby Got Back, the Seattle rapper's new iPhone app, which gives you not only the ode to booty to play whenever you want but also a hilariously bawdy photo-editing tool called Mix's Makeover that enables you to expand the derriere of any lover, friend or foe in your photo library to bubble-tastic proportions.

Los Angeles Times Articles