YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Reversal of Amanda Knox verdict won't quell debate

Italy frees the U.S. student and her ex-boyfriend after they are exonerated in the murder of her roommate, Meredith Kercher. The outcome is unlikely to silence critics on both sides of the divide.

October 03, 2011|By Henry Chu, Los Angeles Times
  • Amanda Knox is overwhelmed on hearing her murder conviction has been overturned in Perugia, Italy.
Amanda Knox is overwhelmed on hearing her murder conviction has been overturned… (Pool photo )

Reporting from London — The case was a media sensation from the start, with allegations of drug-fueled group sex and a principal suspect whose cherubic face proved to be an irresistible canvas to a world that saw in it images ranging from scheming vamp to innocent ingenue.

For four years, that contrast hovered over the fate of Amanda Knox, a 24-year-old American exchange student in Italy, trapped in a foreign legal system and behind bars for the murder of her British roommate. Was she a killer, capable of murdering Meredith Kercher in the pursuit of sexual pleasure? Or was she the helpless victim of a prosecutor's character assassination and a botched police investigation?

On Monday, an appeals jury in the central Italian town of Perugia sided with the latter portrait. It overturned Knox's conviction for the 2007 murder of Kercher, a student with whom she shared an apartment. Knox's alleged accomplice, former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito, 27, was also exonerated by the appellate panel.

Photos: Amanda Knox

The stunning turnaround hinged on an independent review of DNA evidence that authorities said tied Knox and Sollecito to the crime. Kercher, 21, was found dead in her room, her throat slashed and her body bearing more than 40 stab wounds and signs of sexual assault.

The DNA review found that the evidence was severely compromised by sloppy police collection methods and subpar forensic testing, a devastating conclusion that prosecutors could not successfully counter.

Two hours after the verdict was read and beamed around the world, Knox was set free, leaving behind the cell where she has spent most of her adult life. Both she and Sollecito had more than 20 years left to serve under sentences handed down upon their conviction in 2009.

But the acquittals are unlikely to quell public debate, especially among Italians who feel their judicial system has been smeared by the American media and others who accuse the authorities in Perugia of railroading Knox in a staggering miscarriage of justice.

Prosecutors have pledged to appeal the case to Italy's high court, although that body tends to rule on technical points of law rather than on the matters of evidence and character that were presented during the appeals trial.

"We're thankful that Amanda's nightmare is over," her sister Deanna told reporters outside the courtroom, where crowds on either side of the case shouted, "Victory, victory!" and "Shame, shame!" "We are thankful to the court for having the courage to look for the truth and to overturn the conviction," she said.

Kercher's family said it respected the verdict but did "not understand how the decision of the first trial could be so radically overturned. We still trust the Italian judicial system and hope that the truth will eventually emerge."

The victim's relatives had previously declared themselves satisfied with the convictions from the original trial and wanted to see them upheld. Now the Kerchers are left with grave questions about the police's handling of the investigation.

Only one person remains in prison in connection with Kercher's death: Rudy Hermann Guede, a small-time drug dealer and drifter. Guede's DNA was found at the scene, leading to his conviction and sentence of 16 years in prison, but he maintains his innocence and has fingered Knox and Sollecito as the killers.

The pair's attorneys say Guede acted alone in the attack. Sollecito and Knox have insisted they spent the evening in question watching a movie at Sollecito's house, smoking pot and having sex, and were nowhere near the apartment Knox and Kercher shared.

"If I had been there as well, I would have been dead as well as Meredith," Knox said in a tearful final plea to the jury Monday morning, before the panel retired to deliberate.

Prosecutors alleged that she and Sollecito, who had been dating for less than a week, killed Kercher in a sex game gone wrong. Authorities said Knox's DNA was present on a knife believed to be the murder weapon and that Sollecito's DNA was found on the clasp of a bra belonging to Kercher.

But the case against them began to crumble during the appeals trial when an independent review commissioned by the defense cast major doubt on the DNA evidence's reliability. Police detectives had failed to change their gloves when picking up different items in the apartment, making contamination of samples likely, and the bra clasp was not taken away for testing until 46 days after the slaying.

Prosecutors said they stood by the DNA tests. But in overturning the convictions, the jury described the evidence in the case as not credible.

The panel did uphold a conviction against Knox of slander, for her false accusation that a Congolese barman, Diya "Patrick" Lumumba, killed Kercher. But the three-year prison sentence for that conviction has already been fulfilled by the time she spent in jail.

Los Angeles Times Articles