Advertisement
YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollectionsNews

Op-Ed

Drawn to extremes in France

Jean-Luc Melenchon on the left and Marine Le Pen on the right make for a fascinating, and worrisome, presidential election.

April 12, 2012|By Robert Zaretsky
  • The French Fifth Republic is less than two weeks away from the first round of its presidential elections. Jean-Luc Melenchon, leader of the extreme Left Party, has barreled into third place with 15%, leading by a neck Marine Le Pen of the extreme right-wing National Front.
The French Fifth Republic is less than two weeks away from the first round… (Pascal Pochard-Casabianca…)

With Rick Santorum's decision to end his campaign, the outcome of the Republican primaries is decided. But a different republican primary is just now heating up. The French Fifth Republic is 10 days away from the first round of its presidential elections.

The latest polls show the two front-runners, the Gaullist (and current president) Nicolas Sarkozy and Socialist Francois Hollande, have each captured slightly less than 30% of the electorate. But the real news is in the pack that follows: Jean-Luc Melenchon, leader of the extreme Left Party, has barreled into third place with 15%, leading by a neck Marine Le Pen of the extreme right-wing National Front.

That these candidates, lodged at either end of the French political spectrum, are vying for third place is not a coincidence. And the peculiar nature ofFrance's electoral system makes their contest all the more fascinating — and worrisome.

Like the American primaries,France'stwo-round electoral system helps separate the wheat from the chaff. At the same time, though, it allows voters to demonstrate their attachment to this or that indigestible husk or, put another way, their lack of appetite for the typical, some might say bland, grain of wheat. Usually, they register their base instincts, and then dutifully swallow the wheat in the second round, held two weeks later.

Yet this logic fails disastrously at times. In 2002, voters on the left, disenchanted by the colorless Socialist candidate, Lionel Jospin, either delivered their votes to protest candidates or didn't vote at all in Round 1. The indigestible, in this case, led to the unspeakable:Jean-Marie Le Pen, anti-Semitic and thuggish founder of the National Front, finished in second place — shocking the left into voting for the Gaullist candidate, Jacques Chirac.

Thanks to Melenchon, abstention on the left will not be an issue this time around. He began his mad dash up the polls at a mass meeting at the Bastille. Wearing a trademark red tie, he addressed a crowd of 100,000, speckled with red signs, red flags and red caps — Phrygian-style, one of the emblems of the French Revolution — and called for a "civic insurrection" against a nation "disfigured by inequalities" and a "French volcano" preparing to explode.

The crowd was galvanized, but rather than erupting across Paris, it peacefully dispersed into the Metro, buses and cafes. This was hardly reassuring to some observers, who half expected to see a guillotine planted by Melenchon's podium. One business leader asserted that a vote for Melenchon was a vote for the Terror.

But the leader most worried about the future, if not his head, is Hollande, who has watched with growing frustration as the fiery Melenchon drains off disaffected Socialist voters. Known as "Monsieur Normal," Hollande initially won over the French left for the simple reason that he was not Dominique Strauss-Kahn, with his legal woes and his women problems. Indeed, if Hollande resembles another politician, it is Mitt Romney: A technocrat with little government experience, Hollande is willing to pander to his base to win its support.

And pander he has. His recent proposal to slap a 75% income tax rate on France's wealthiest citizens was widely seen as an effort to defuse Melenchon's proposals to transform France's generous safety net into a veritable hammock, with a dramatic increase in the monthly minimum wage and a guaranteed full pension upon retirement at age 60.

But Hollande's strategy seems to have backfired. Soon after his proposal, he visited London to woo the tens of thousands of French expatriates who left home precisely because of their country's punishing tax rates. He announced, in English, "I am not dangerous," But Melenchon only grabbed the remark and turned it around: "I am dangerous," he regularly announces to his delighted crowds.

Though she would never utter the phrase, so too is Marine Le Pen, daughter of Jean-Marie. She has striven to repackage the National Front, disassociating herself from her father's forays into Holocaust denial, declaring that she has "a different vision of the past." Yet her attitude toward Muslims is as brutal as was her father's toward Jews. Referring to French Muslims praying on the streets of Paris, she has described France as living under a "new occupation" and insists that an untold number of Mohamed Merahs, the gunman who took the lives of seven Jews, Christians and Muslims last month, arrive every day on French soil.

More ominously, Le Pen has coupled fears over immigration and "Islamism" to an elusive but real anxiety over globalization. Like her hero Joan of Arc, Le Pen sees traitors everywhere who have sold out the nation — in this case not to the English but to European Union bureaucrats in Brussels and the captains of global capitalism.

Advertisement
Los Angeles Times Articles
|
|
|