YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Plenty of advice for L.A. Unified's boss

Teachers, substitutes and the columnist offer some words of wisdom for Supt. John Deasy regarding a classroom confrontation with a sub who was following the regular instructor's lesson plan.

April 14, 2012|Sandy Banks
  • L.A. Unified Supt. John Deasy's classroom dust-up with a substitute teacher has produced an outpouring of responses and advice.
L.A. Unified Supt. John Deasy's classroom dust-up with a substitute… (Al Seib / Los Angeles Times )

Any day now, I expect to see a crowd of substitute teachers marching around Los Angeles Unified School District headquarters, wearing signs that say "I AM PATRENA SHANKLING" and waving lists of dumb things that substitutes have been asked to do.

Shankling is the substitute teacher fired by Supt. John Deasy last fall, after he scolded her for giving 12th-grade students what he considered busywork: copying class procedures from a sheet of paper into their composition books.

Since a Times profile on Deasy and my column this week on the incident, teachers have rallied to Shankling's defense, describing in emails, letters and online comments the hard life of a substitute.

"Deasy doesn't seem to grasp the reality of the role of a substitute teacher," wrote Marie Brown, a former sub in a district outside of L.A. Unified. "We don't work if the teachers do not 'like us,' " her email said. "And, from my experience, teachers do not like any feedback from subs that is implicitly critical."

Deasy, trying to raise the academic bar, considered Shankling's rote assignment a waste of students' time. And he bristled at her "I'm just following orders" response when he questioned her in class about it.

But Brown said Shankling's students were lucky that the substitute had a lesson plan to go on.

"I was rarely given instructions to actually teach something," Brown wrote. "It is always busy work.…Thus, your major goal becomes keeping students quiet and in their seats....Many times I have thought how disturbed the general public would be if they knew what I know."

If you're the parent of a student who has been through public school, you might already know. You've heard the stories of unruly classes, pointless movies and oddball subs.

The typical student spends the equivalent of one school year with a substitute. Some are newly minted teachers, others career changers or retirees. Many are flexible and competent, but know nothing about the students they're assigned and little about the subjects they're asked to teach.

"The school is not interested in your area of expertise," wrote a sub from Santa Clarita. "They want to know if you can fog a mirror."

Fogging a mirror isn't enough. Ask Arthur Christopher Schaper, who spent last year subbing at schools in the Centinela Valley Union High School District. He was cursed out and mocked in class, and had things thrown at him by students so undisciplined their previous teachers had resigned, he said.

Now he's better at his job and he's satisfied with his sub assignments at Lawndale's Leuzinger High.

In hindsight he knows his learning curve shortchanged his former students. "When I accepted that teaching just is not my bag," he wrote, "I could look back on what I endured, and say, 'I made out like a bandit, compared to those kids....' "


What struck me most in the reader feedback was the cynicism of so many teachers who feel under fire and disillusioned, bombarded by waves of mandated "reforms" that have little to do with the challenges they encounter in their classrooms.

The superintendent, they said, ought to walk in their shoes. "He's the best we've had since I began teaching secondary English, mid-'80s," wrote Jim Rodriguez of Whittier. "HOWEVER, his tirade, the second day of a new school year, was just plain nuts."

Deasy did have his defenders, impressed by his commitment to improvement and shocked by the academic deficiencies of the students Shankling was teaching that morning.

"The real horror is how inept these senior students are in the understanding and use of the English language. Who do they think will hire them when they are unable to send even a simple memo that is grammatically correct?" asked Carolyn Ziegler-Davenport, whose children and grandchildren graduated from public schools.

"I would much rather have a person like Deasy, who understands this, in charge," she said, "than yet another apologist unwilling to make tough calls."


Deasy began his career as a high school teacher in Rhode Island, but his expertise is in the intricacies of school reform. That's the hat he expected to wear when he signed on in Los Angeles.

Instead, he's been bombarded with challenges whose collective dimensions he couldn't have imagined, including a budget squeeze that's gutted programs and forced layoffs, and a teacher sex-abuse scandal that's unfolding like a horror story.

Deasy hasn't asked, but here's my advice, as someone who's tracked this district for 25 years and ushered three children through its schools:

Decide what you want your legacy to be. Focus on the big things and file away the others.

Ten minutes wasted rewriting class rules is nothing to get worked up about. If that enraged the superintendent, we're lucky he didn't visit the science class where the sub had been ordered by the absent teacher to screen Will Smith's "I Am Legend," a movie about predatory, cannibalistic beings.

Take a lesson from your predecessors.

Los Angeles Times Articles