YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Hollywood trying to avoid villain role in film violence

Last week's 'Dark Knight Rises' theater massacre has TV and film industry vets confronting their use of violence, even as such imagery plays big at the box office.

July 28, 2012|By Alex Pham, Steven Zeitchik and Ben Fritz, Los Angeles Times Staff Writers
  • "Sons of Anarchy” creator Kurt Sutter tweeted that instances like the shooting caused him to question his “liberal use” of violence in his storytelling.
"Sons of Anarchy” creator Kurt Sutter tweeted that instances… (Gary Friedman, Los Angeles…)

The mass shooting at a "Dark Knight Rises" screening last week has Hollywood quietly squirming. Despite the entertainment industry's famously liberal leanings, violent content has long been its stock in trade — leading creators of movies, TV shows and video games to contemplate what role if any their work may have played in the violence.

The fact that the Aurora, Colo. massacre occurred at a post-midnight screening of a film depicting murder and mayhem nonetheless has triggered a rare bout of soul searching in Hollywood.

"Like every person who works in movies and is following this event, I'm asking myself what are we responsible for, if anything," said Rob Cohen, a director-producer of edgy films such as "XXX," "Stealth" and the upcoming "Alex Cross."

PHOTOS: Scene of the shooting | Hollywood reacts

"Some say we're complicit in this violence and I'm not sure we are," he said. "But, it does give me great pause. We want our movies to be shown to the widest possible audience — we are in a commercial business — but I now have to look deeper."

Kurt Sutter, the writer-producer of such TV shows as"Sons of Anarchy"and "The Shield," is also looking inward.

"Woke up to the news about shooting," he said in a Twitter message last Friday after 12 people were killed and 58 injured. "This kinda thing always makes me question my liberal use of violence in storytelling."

TIMELINE: Mass shootings in the U.S.

All over Hollywood, studio executives, filmmakers and other entertainment professionals were having similar conversations. But few were willing to talk on the record, fearing that their comments may suggest a link between violence and violent images that has not been empirically established.

And then there is this: Violence is good for the box office. Talking about corporate responsibility to tone down on-screen aggression could leave executives open to accusations of hypocrisy when they release their next blood-soaked blockbuster.

Gun control, not Hollywood violence, should be the topic of the moment, one studio executive said. That too, however, was not for attribution.

VICTIMS: Who they were

Warner Bros., which released "The Dark Knight Rises," has come under the most scrutiny. Over the weekend, the studio took the rare step of not releasing box office receipts for what is shaping up to be one of the year's biggest blockbusters. On Monday the Burbank studio released the weekend's ticket sales, without crowing that it was the third biggest opening ever.

Warner also tiptoed through its decision to donate money to victims of the shooting, declining to divulge the amount and doing so without the fanfare and news releases that normally accompany such contributions. The studio also decided to delay the release of its upcoming film "Gangster Squad" in order to edit a scene featuring a shoot-up in a movie theater.

Independent producer Harvey Weinstein, who has released all of director Quentin Tarantino's violence-laden films — from "Pulp Fiction" to his upcoming revenge picture "Django Unchained" — suggested to the Huffington Post that he, Tarantino, Martin Scorsese and "all of us who deal in violence in movies" should sit down ... and discuss our role in that."

PHOTOS: Hollywood backlot moments

Kevin Reilly, entertainment president Fox Broadcasting, called what happened a "terrible tragedy," however he did not think it would affect his network as it is already trying to be careful with the level of violence on the screen.

"I don't anticipate any changes in our business," Reilly said, as the network routinely polices its airwaves. "We look at everything."

Hollywood, of course, wasn't the first to inject violence into storytelling.

"From the cave paintings of animal hunts to 'The Iliad,' action and adventure have been an integral part in storytelling," said Frank Gibeau, studio president of Electronic Arts, a video game publisher based in Redwood City, Calif., that puts out "The Sims," "Madden NFL" and "Medal of Honor," a shooting game borne out of Steven Spielberg's film"Saving Private Ryan."

"But it's hard to imagine how someone can suggest that the film playing that night in any way provoked this horrible crime," Gibeau said. "Rational people know the difference between fantasy and real violence."

Most researchers agree that at best, on-screen violence is one of many risk factors contributing to aggressive, though not necessarily criminal, behavior.

For mass shootings, "there are other factors such as antisocial personality, depression, psychosis, suicidal tendencies and so on," said Steve Kirsh, professor of psychology at the State University of New York in Geneseo and the author of "Media and Youth: A Developmental Perspective." "Media violence isn't even considered an influence."

Los Angeles Times Articles