YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Syria peace plan not working, U.N. envoy Kofi Annan says

Kofi Annan tells the United Nations that Syria is headed toward civil war. Diplomats consider involving Iran in negotiations with Bashar Assad's government.

June 07, 2012|By Patrick J. McDonnell, Los Angeles Times
  • Rebel fighters receive training on the outskirts of Idlib, Syria. "The crisis is escalating," U.N. envoy Kofi Annan said. "The violence is getting worse. The abuses are continuing. The country is becoming more polarized and more radicalized."
Rebel fighters receive training on the outskirts of Idlib, Syria. "The… (Associated Press )

BEIRUT — Employing his gloomiest assessment to date, United Nations special envoy Kofi Annan acknowledged Thursday that his six-point peace plan was not working and warned that Syria was headed down a path of "brutal repression, massacres, sectarian violence and even all-out civil war."

His address came as he and other officials condemned a massacre of dozens of civilians near the central city of Hama, and as diplomats proposed crafting a new strategy to bring peace to Syria that would engage other Middle East countries, including Iran.

Addressing the U.N. General Assembly in New York, Annan urged world leaders to make it clear that failing to comply with the plan would carry unspecified consequences, presumably for Syrian President Bashar Assad, whose government, Annan said, bore the "first responsibility" for ending the violence.

"We cannot allow mass killing to become part of everyday reality in Syria," Annan said. "The crisis is escalating. The violence is getting worse. The abuses are continuing. The country is becoming more polarized and more radicalized. And Syria's immediate neighbors are increasingly worried about the threat of spillover."

Annan said that unless the fighting is halted, "all Syrians will lose."

After a closed-door meeting of the U.N. Security Council later, Annan spoke dejectedly of the prospects for his plan resulting in a negotiated settlement of the conflict and alluded to the need to consider other actions "if the plan is not working, or if we decide it's not the way to go."

Annan made it clear that divisions persist among key Security Council members on the scope of actions that should be considered, and he called for unity on the idea of including all regional forces with influence on either the Assad regime or the rebel groups fighting him.

"Syria is not Libya. It won't implode; it will explode beyond its borders," Annan said. Refugee outflows to Turkey and Jordan and sectarian fighting in Lebanon already demonstrate that the conflict threatens the entire region, he said.

It remained unclear how new intermediaries would succeed where Annan's plan failed. The proposed "contact group" would still be deeply divided between the U.S. and European nations urging bolder intervention and sanctions on Damascus, and Russia and China, which would presumably be backed by newcomer Iran in their steadfast rejection of those measures.

U.S. and British officials have balked at any inclusion of Tehran, a staunch ally of Assad and the regional nemesis of the West. But Russia has backed the idea of an expanded meeting of nations that have influence with various factions in the 15-month-old uprising.

The forum being pushed by Moscow would include the five permanent members of the Security Council — the United States, Russia, China, Britain and France — the Arab League, the Organization of the Islamic Conference and Syrian neighbors Turkey and Iran.

At the General Assembly on Thursday, Russia and China reiterated their support for the Annan peace plan but also reaffirmed their opposition to any solution involving military intervention in Syria or forced "regime change," though both nations have said Assad's survival is not a precondition if the Syrian people choose otherwise. The two powers have twice vetoed Security Council resolutions that condemned Assad's crackdown on dissent and could have led to sanctions or other action against his government.

The United States and its allies, meantime, say Assad's departure is a necessary outcome of any peace plan. The Obama administration is trying to persuade Russia to get aboard a plan similar to what happened in Yemen, where President Ali Abdullah Saleh was eased out of power and replaced by his former deputy after a year of protests.

The State Department's special representative on Syria, Fred Hof, was in Moscow on Thursday for talks with the Russians, the department said. There was no immediate word of the outcome of those talks.

In Istanbul, Turkey, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton made it clear that the Annan plan — with its call for a cease-fire and withdrawal of government troops and heavy weapons from populated areas — is only one part of what Washington and its allies seek. In addition, Assad "must transfer power and depart Syria" and an "interim representative government must be established through negotiation," Clinton said.

"The time has come for the international community to unite around a plan for post-Assad Syria," Clinton said after meeting with Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu.

Although the Annan blueprint has widespread backing, the forced departure of Assad seemed to remain a red line for Russia and China.

Los Angeles Times Articles