YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Mubarak health reports leave Egypt confused and suspicious

Egyptians yearn to move beyond the 30-year rule of the imprisoned president, but reports that he was near death struck many as just another political ploy.

June 20, 2012|By Jeffrey Fleishman, Los Angeles Times
  • Egyptian soldiers guard the military hospital in Cairo's Maadi district, where former President Hosni Mubarak was on life support. A lawyer for the deposed leader said his health was improving.
Egyptian soldiers guard the military hospital in Cairo's Maadi district,… (Amr Nabil / Associated Press…)

CAIRO — Egypt is a land of angry, puzzled faces.

The sense of balance — if one ever existed in a country where chaos is as ancient and enduring as the pyramids — evaporates in whispers of unease. From bread lines to cafes and from stately neighborhoods to slanting shantytowns, Egyptians simmer with disgust over their unsated revolution.

Heroes and villains slip in and out of narratives as the man responsible for the turmoil — Hosni Mubarak — lies near death, or so the public has been told, in a military hospital overlooking the Nile. His countrymen yearn to move beyond his 30-year rule and impenetrable visage, but he haunts them even in his pallor, an aged patriarch refusing to set free the nation he treated as belonging to him, his jailed sons and his wife of countless jewels.

Egyptian news reports late Tuesday that said Mubarak was "clinically dead" sent fireworks into the night and cheers among the banners blowing in Cairo's Tahrir Square. But like so much else in Egypt, things were not as they first appeared. Officials hurried out their own statement: Mubarak, sentenced to life in prison this month for complicity in the murder of hundreds of protesters in the uprising that toppled him last year, was actually in critical condition and on life support.

The fireworks had stopped and the cheers faded long before Wednesday's first light. Many believed that the army had exaggerated the fallen leader's ailments as a ploy to move him from a prison hospital to the more comfortable military complex. Such suspicion has persisted throughout a series of dire announcements on Mubarak's health — a few coming at sensitive times in his legal ordeal — including reports that emerged later Wednesday that Mubarak was in a coma.

"I didn't buy the news of Mubarak's death because he's died many times before. They keep provoking us. It's like they're sticking their tongues out at the people," said Maged Tawfiles, a university student in Cairo. "Nothing has changed. We're tired, fed up and divided. I'm constantly confused."

Yousri Abdelrazeq, an attorney for Mubarak, attributed the suggestions that his client was near death to media rumors. He said Mubarak was transferred to the military hospital after receiving improper medical treatment in Tora prison. "His health is improving," Abdelrazeq said, "and he's stable."

Since Mubarak departed from his palace by helicopter on Feb. 11, 2011, celebrations have erupted and abruptly ended, like passing storms: The army seized power; everyone was happy. The generals stayed too long; many were outraged. The Muslim Brotherhood was respected; suddenly it was not. An Islamist-dominated parliament was elected; Egypt's highest court dissolved it.

On and on it goes, good news veering into bad.

Tensions rose further when the national election commission said Wednesday that announcement of the winner of last weekend's presidential runoff would be delayed a few days. The ruling military, which, like Mubarak, is loath to relinquish its grip on the state, has shorn the president's office of much of its power. The projected winner is Muslim Brotherhood candidate Mohamed Morsi, a conservative Islamist, whose ascendancy poses a political threat to the authority and riches of the secular Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, or SCAF.

"There is no doubt SCAF is behind all of these back-to-back decisions that are wearing us out," said Omar Shawki, a writer. "People don't even want to talk about politics. The military has created a sense of confusion in the street.... Nobody trusts anybody right now."

Between unsettling revelations and fear of violence, Egyptians recall those bright wintry days of 2011 when the world watched in wonder as they swarmed colonial-era Tahrir Square with placards and songs to bring down the modern-day pharaoh. They bragged back then that their revolution would inspire the Arab world to a new epoch. They don't murmur such promises much anymore. Their rage and disappointment are too great.

They survive — bricklayer, fishmonger, Twitter wizard and banker — with conflicting emotions. Activists, inexperienced and overwhelmed, speak of a new rebellion. The Brotherhood and revolutionary groups drew thousands into Tahrir on Tuesday night. But many others are weary of unprecedented crime, demonstrations and economic hardship. Ahmed Shafik, a Mubarak ally and Morsi's presidential challenger, promised law and order and an end to turmoil and, despite his links to the fallen leader, drew the support of millions of voters.

Los Angeles Times Articles