Chatsworth credit union demise ignites pay, business loan debate

March 26, 2012|By E. Scott Reckard
  • The National Credit Union Administration took over failed Telesis Community Credit Union in Chatsworth on Friday. Member accounts are insured for up to $250,000.
The National Credit Union Administration took over failed Telesis Community… (National Credit Union Administration )

The failure of Telesis Community Credit Union in Chatsworth provides a behind-the-scenes glimpse into controversies over business lending and multimillion-dollar executive pay at some of the member-owned financial cooperatives.

State financial regulators late Friday seized Telesis, a financially troubled institution that remains open under control of the National Credit Union Administration. The NCUA oversees a federal insurance program for credit union accounts up to $250,000.

Telesis was among 120 credit unions that NCUA exempted from a usual limit of no more than 12.25% of assets in business loans larger than $50,000.

Its woes, along with those of giant Texans Credit Union and other specialists in member business loans, provide ammunition for banking lobbyists opposing a credit union-backed bill lifting the limits, which is being considered in the Congress.

"Telesis ... is a case study in how disastrous expanded MBL [member business loan] levels can be for the credit union sector,” Paul Merski, chief economist for a community bankers group, told the Credit Union Journal. 

The lobbyists say tax-exempt credit unions should convert themselves into mutual savings banks, which pay taxes, if they want to do more business lending.

Telesis' failure also reignited a debate over multimillion-dollar pay packages awarded to some credit union leaders. Telesis paid its chief executive officer, Grace Mayo, more than $2.1 million in 2010, a year in which it lost more than $11 million.

A spokesman told the Credit Union Times that the payment was actually part of a cost-saving measure in which senior executives forfeited large deferred compensation packages in return for big one-time payouts.

Telesis' soured business credits included a California resort project, a Memphis historic development and a Florida shopping mall, according to reports.


Regulators take over Telesis Community Credit Union

Credit unions aren't immune from financial crisis

Kinecta, NuVision credit unions call off merger

Los Angeles Times Articles