YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

On abortion, Arlen Specter mixed principle and politics

October 16, 2012|By Michael McGough
  • Sen. Arlen Specter reacts to being acknowledged by President Obama at a 2009 event at the National Institutes of Health.
Sen. Arlen Specter reacts to being acknowledged by President Obama at a… (Gerald Herbert / Associated…)

The death of Arlen Specter inspired a predictably conflicted reaction from supporters of abortion rights: He was the guy who kept Robert Bork off the Supreme Court, perhaps in the process saving Roe vs. Wade --  Specter's favorite "super-duper precedent." But he also was the pitiless inquisitor of Anita Hill and may thus have been instrumental in the confirmation of Justice Clarence Thomas -- and Thomas is no friend of Roe.  (In 2007, Thomas wrote that "the court's abortion jurisprudence ... has no basis in the Constitution." 

The cynical view, of course, is that while Specter genuinely supported abortion rights, he was first and foremost a supporter of Arlen Specter. After alienating conservatives with his vote against Bork (with whom he differed on more than abortion; he also pounced on Bork's 1st Amendment views), Specter, according to this view, tried to win back some of them by supporting Thomas. (Thomas was confirmed in 1991; Specter was up for renomination and reelection in 1992.)  

That wasn't Specter's last recalibration. After the 2004 election, Specter injudiciously announced that the Senate would not confirm any Supreme Court nominee who would overturn Roe. Oops. Conservatives mobilized to deny Specter the chairmanship of the Judiciary Committee, which handles judicial nominations. Specter salvaged his chairmanship by indicating that he would likely support George W.  Bush's nominees and wouldn't impose an abortion litmus test.

That put him in a position to hector John G. Roberts Jr. and Samuel A. Alito Jr. on the importance of respecting Roe vs. Wade.  Still, unlike other senators who favor abortion rights, he voted for both men. 

If one or both participate in a future decision reversing or reining in Roe, Specter's fancy footwork won't look so good. On abortion, as with other issues, Specter had his principles; his first principle was political self-preservation.


Kinsley: The politics of common sense

Biden and Romney: What their gaffes secretly say about them

Photos: 7 politicians who shouldn't be reelected -- but may be anyway

Los Angeles Times Articles