YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Fox denies 'Idol' scheme to dump Mariah Carey for Jennifer Lopez

April 24, 2013|By Yvonne Villarreal
  • Jennifer Lopez, left, and Mariah Carey.
Jennifer Lopez, left, and Mariah Carey. (Michael Buckner, Kevin…)

Fox is denying a report that "American Idol" considered coaxing "Jenny From the Block" to make a U-turn on the "American Idol" judging street.

A story from The Hollywood Reporter said a dip in ratings had producers scrambling to find a solution to bail out the long-running singing competition series: swapping Mariah Carey for former "Idol" judge Jennifer Lopez came to mind. A scheme that apparently was halted when Mariah Carey threatened legal action.

A Fox spokesperson denied the conspiracy, while hinting that Lopez could return for the show's upcoming finale.

PHOTOS: 'American Idol' - Where are they now?

"This is just another ridiculous 'Idol' judge rumor, likely started by talks of Jennifer performing on the finale," the spokesperson said.

Fremantle North America, which produces the show, did not immediately return requests for comment.

"American Idol" had a seemingly solid start with the launch of its 12th season, which featured yet another new set of faces: Nicki Minaj, Keith Urban and Carey joined longtime judge Randy Jackson. The show's premiere brought in nearly 18 million viewers and a not-too-shabby 6.0 rating in the advertiser-favorite 18-49 demo. While still hefty, the long-running show has seen its double-digit dip in ratings for a second year in a row.

GRAPHIC: Pick the next 'American Idol' judge

And the 12th season would get wobbly from there, while genre competitor "The Voice" gained traction and Thursday time slot competitor "The Big Bang Theory" closing in with total viewers.

Of the new judges, Minaj has stood out with her flamboyant personality, while Carey has failed to excite viewers. Though the network is denying any current changes to the lineup, let's not be surprised if changes come once the season is over.

And, hey, if "Idol" does find itself looking for another judge come next season, why not go for something more outside the box? Like, maybe, Ann Curry or that news anchor dude that got fired for cursing on air.

Just some suggestions.


TV networks look to pilots to help boost ratings

NBC orders new reality series "The Million Second Quiz"

Yvonne Villarreal



Real places, fake characters: TV's bars and eateries

Real places, fake characters: TV's bars and eateries

PHOTOS: 'The Ellen DeGeneres Show' through the years

PHOTOS: 'The Ellen DeGeneres Show' through the years

PHOTOS: Violence in TV shows

Los Angeles Times Articles