Advertisement
YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollectionsNews

Pope's resignation reshapes traditions

Benedict's decision to step down unnerves the usually plodding church leadership; cardinals have shown an unusual feistiness in the more open atmosphere.

March 12, 2013|By Tracy Wilkinson, Los Angeles Times
  • Cardinals enter the Sistine Chapel before the conclave begins.
Cardinals enter the Sistine Chapel before the conclave begins. (L'Osservatore Romano /…)

VATICAN CITY — Eight years ago, many of the men with red caps and red cloaks who walked into the Sistine Chapel to choose a pope seemed to be in a state of grief-shaped numbness.

The only pope most had known for their professional lives as cardinals had died. The funeral had been an ornate, somber affair, replete with the evocation of the saints and the attendance of heads of state from the world over, not to mention millions of pilgrims.

The cardinals were eager for guidance. And that guidance, that leadership, swiftly showed itself in the person of Joseph Ratzinger, officially the dean of cardinals, who calmly, expertly led the prayer services, conversed with cardinals in their native languages and outlined what they needed to do.

PHOTOS: Vatican Conclave 2013

No wonder Ratzinger was elected to replace Pope John Paul II, who had reigned for 26 years, in less than 24 hours. It was one of the shortest conclaves in history.

Today is very different, a cascade of events triggered by the first resignation of a pope in six centuries. Benedict's decision to step down at age 85 has turned the usual calculation about success and process on its head. It completely unnerved the usually plodding, meticulously choreographed church leadership. Precedents have been shattered; and while one cannot say that anything can happen, there certainly is a much wider range of possibilities.

Not weighed down by the force of grief and mourning, the 115 cardinals gathered here to pick Benedict's replacement have shown an unusual feistiness, an inquisitiveness that was not seen the last time around and that has drawn out proceedings and scrambled candidacies for the successor. Surely there is much to discuss, from scandals involving sexual abuse to allegations of money laundering by the Vatican bank.

Cardinals delivered more than 150 speeches in 10 pre-conclave meetings, known as congregations. When the final session concluded Monday, there were still several prelates who had signed up to speak but were cut off because time had run out, Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi said.

That glimpse inside the congregations offered further evidence that the cardinals have been thrown for a loop by Benedict's stunning resignation. They also apparently feel more free to speak their mind: The solemnity that the 2005 funeral and attendant Masses infused in the atmosphere is absent in 2013.

FULL COVERAGE: Choosing a pope

Where Ratzinger had a leading role in the conclave, this year's dean of cardinals, Angelo Sodano, led the final Mass before the conclave but, at age 85, is too old to participate in the voting itself.

And though cardinals in 2005 were in mourning, most had known for quite a while that the day they would be gathering to select a new pope was imminent. Perhaps some had settled on their candidate well before filing into the Sistine Chapel.

"John Paul's illness was very long and we had already prepared psychologically to elect a successor," the well-respected Cardinal Paul Poupard of France, now 82, was quoted as saying in Tuesday's La Stampa newspaper. "This time the difference is abyssal. The resignation of Benedict has really been a bolt of lightning, out of the blue, for everyone."

In an institution accustomed to moving at its own, millennial pace, the lack of a clear front-runner to occupy St. Peter's chair has created an air of unpredictability that has disconcerted veterans, pundits and the Catholic faithful. Although the name of Cardinal Angelo Scola, the archbishop of Milan, often comes up, he by no means has a lock.

"What we are living is an extraordinary conclave," longtime Vatican watcher Marco Tosatti wrote this week in his blog. "Not just because it's a conclave that has to elect a pope while another one is still alive. But because in the last century there's never been this much uncertainty."

This papal transition marked another first: A cardinal declined to attend the conclave because of personal scandal. Keith O'Brien of Scotland resigned from public clerical life last month, acknowledging unspecific sexual misbehavior days after several priests made allegations against him.

In modern times, no cardinal has ever skipped a conclave — participation in which is considered a cardinal's primordial duty — except in cases of severe health problems.

Cardinals have hinted strongly that they want a pope who is a firm-handed, clearheaded governor who can attend to a Vatican administration that Benedict is judged to have neglected. But there are also urgings for a "pastoral" pope with great communication skills who can reach out to an increasingly disaffected Catholic world.

"Let us pray to the Holy Spirit to illumine the church to choose a new pope who will confirm us in our faith and make more visible ... the love of the church," Cardinal Sean O'Malley of Boston said before the conclave.

Advertisement
Los Angeles Times Articles
|
|
|