YOU ARE HERE: LAT HomeCollections

Germany raid yields 1,500 artworks possibly seized by Nazis

Cornelius Gurlitt's Munich apartment held paintings that included works thought lost or destroyed during World War II. His father was a Nazi-era art dealer.

November 04, 2013|By Henry Chu
  • Cornelius Gurlitt's apartment in this building in Munich, Germany, held 1,500 works of art that had been seized by the Nazis. The art, found crammed amid piles of canned food, is estimated to be worth $1.3 billion or more.
Cornelius Gurlitt's apartment in this building in Munich, Germany,… (Christof Stache / AFP/Getty…)

LONDON — The elderly gentleman appeared nervous when authorities questioned him during a customs check aboard a train from Switzerland to Germany. He was carrying about $12,000 in cash, just within the legal limit.

But a feeling that something was not quite right eventually led them several months later to raid the apartment in Munich where the man lived as a recluse.

What they found was astonishing: paintings by Pablo Picasso, Marc Chagall, Henri Matisse and Paul Klee among 1,500 works of art crammed amid piles of canned food. Some or all of the art, estimated to be worth $1.3 billion or more, was thought to have been looted by the Nazis more than 70 years ago. That would make it one of the largest such troves recovered since World War II.

The stunning find was reported Sunday by the German newsmagazine Focus. It said the collection found in the possession of Cornelius Gurlitt, the 80-year-old son of a well-know Nazi-era art dealer, included pieces that were thought to have been lost or destroyed during the war.

"It is the largest cache held by a private individual illegally — by miles," Julian Radcliffe, chairman of the Art Loss Register in London, which tracks vanished works of art, said Monday. "Two years ago we found a dealer who had two stolen pictures in his safe when he died, and we thought that was pretty shocking because he had actually been put in jail by the French in 1946 for being part of the Holocaust looting.... To find one on this scale is exceptional."

Overall, the Nazis are suspected of plundering 650,000 paintings and other artworks, which puts the Munich hoard, for all its unprecedented size, into grim perspective.

Robert Edsel, author of the book "The Monuments Men," which chronicles the search for and recovery of art looted during World War II, said the discovery validated the view that what had been discovered so far was the tip of the iceberg.

"The theft is being solved in what seems like slow motion — one day there might be a story, but the only people following it are art historians or people who follow Nazi looting," said Edsel, whose book is being made into a movie starring George Clooney, Matt Damon and Bill Murray. It will be released early next year.

Edsel said he was working with filmmakers on a project to be announced late this month that will ask the public's help in expediting the recovery of still-missing works of art.

Gurlitt's home was raided in early 2011, Focus reported. German authorities have kept mum as they moved the items into safe storage outside Munich and started to untangle the knot of issues surrounding provenance and rightful ownership.

The German government told reporters Monday that it was notified of the haul several months ago by Bavarian officials and that it was assisting with the investigation.

Many of the original collectors could turn out to be Jewish families who saw their belongings confiscated by the Nazis or who sold them at knock-down prices in their desperation to flee Europe and avoid deportation to the extermination camps.

That the authorities in Bavaria, in southern Germany, took so long to acknowledge their astounding discovery and have yet to publish an inventory disturbs some advocates of reuniting stolen art with their proper owners.

"It doesn't take 2 3/4 years to do that," said Anne Webber, co-chair of the Commission for Looted Art in Europe, a nonprofit organization. "There's a complete lack of transparency about this. Families have been looking for [their] art for 75 years."

Focus reported that 200 of the works taken from Gurlitt's home had international warrants on them.

Of special interest to art historians will be the 300 or so items that may have featured in Adolf Hitler's catalog of "degenerate art," works that did not fit in with his vision of a reactionary, racially pure society. In an infamous 1937 exhibition in Munich, the Nazis displayed 650 such objects — sculptures, paintings, books — with derisive commentaries explaining why artists such as Chagall and Wassily Kandinsky ought to be reviled.

Stephanie Barron, senior curator of modern art at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, said all of the works displayed in the 1937 show came from the collections of German public museums, not private collectors. Barron curated a 1991 LACMA exhibition that attempted to partially reconstruct the 1937 show.

Focus said Gurlitt sold off individual pieces when he needed money. In one instance, the circumstances of which remain unclear, he was able to put a painting by German Expressionist Max Beckmann up for sale at an auction months after his apartment had been raided.

"The Lion Tamer" was not listed in the Art Loss Register's database. Heirs of the original owner somehow got wind of the auction, claimed the painting as theirs and reached a settlement with the auction house, which proceeded with the sale, Webber said. The work fetched nearly $1.2 million.

Los Angeles Times Articles